by Scott Schrage
his functional MRI visualization shows how many of 12 tasks yielded differences in neural activity when study participants gave incorrect versus correct answers, from all 12 (red) to none (black). Credit: UNL Center for Brain, Biology and Behavior
Everyone makes mistakes—so a University of Nebraska-Lincoln psychologist set out to determine how the human brain responds to the errors of its ways.
"The reason to focus on errors is that they're a really pervasive part of our cognition," said Maital Neta, assistant professor of psychology. "They happen in everything that we do, even the simplest tasks. So if you want to get a sense for how something is structured in the brain—regardless of a specific mood or a specific task—then errors are a really good way to do it."
Neta and several colleagues recently published a study showing that even basic errors can trigger neural activity across a much broader swath of the brain than previously thought.
The authors performed functional MRI scans of study participants as they completed 12 diverse tasks that included recognizing parts of speech and mentally rotating three-dimensional shapes to identify matching pairs.
The team found that 41 regions of the brain showed substantial differences in activity following incorrect vs. correct answers on a majority of the tasks.
"Many people in the field of neuroscience have said that there's one primary region of the brain that responds to errors," Neta said. "One of the most interesting aspects of this paper is how it shows that even though that region may be really important, it's not the only one."
The fMRI scans also illustrated that the 41 regions are distributed across several networks of the brain that are otherwise distinguished by differing functions, Neta said.
In addition to analyzing the spatial aspects of error-related activity, the team measured the speed and duration of each region's activation. The researchers subsequently characterized three profiles of neural response: fast, prolonged and delayed. According to Neta, the study revealed that all but one of the brain's networks feature just a single response profile.
Neta's team further discovered that regions of the brain with the same error-related responses also exhibit similar activation patterns while at rest. Even regions residing in separate networks and sides of the brain seem to spontaneously function together when not occupied with an error or task, she said.
"This came out much more clearly than I would have ever expected," Neta said. "It makes a lot of intuitive sense—it's just that most results don't come out quite so perfectly.
"So there's something about this wiring or connectivity that works not only when you're at rest, but also when you're suddenly thrown into a situation that (might produce) an error. There's still a lot we don't know about the brain."
Though Neta's team focused on documenting and cataloging error-related activity, she noted that other researchers could use the study as a starting point for delving into specific linkages between regions and error-related reactions.
"Identifying all these regions is just sort of the first step," Neta said. "People whose research focuses on specifics of error processing could now look at different tasks individually and determine what these regions might be doing."
The study appeared in the Jan. 7 edition of The Journal of Neuroscience.
Explore further: Study finds which brain skills are more likely to last over a lifetime
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Study of brain activity in monkeys shows how the brain processes mistakes made by others
Jan 11, 2013
Humans and other animals learn by making mistakes. They can also learn from observing the mistakes of others. The brain processes self-generated errors in a region called the medial frontal cortex (MFC) but ...
Study finds which brain skills are more likely to last over a lifetime
Jan 09, 2015
Research from the Center for Vital Longevity (CVL) at The University of Texas at Dallas has shed new light on which cognitive processes tend to be preserved with age and which ones decline.
Human brain keeps memories tidy by pruning inaccurate ones
Jan 09, 2015
Forget about it. Your brain is a memory powerhouse, constantly recording experiences in long-term memory. Those memories help you find your way through the world: Who works the counter each morning at your ...
Dyslexic readers have disrupted network connections in the brain
Aug 28, 2014
Dyslexia, the most commonly diagnosed learning disability in the United States, is a neurological reading disability that occurs when the regions of the brain that process written language don't function normally.
Remapping the damaged brain
Jan 06, 2015
Scientists at the RIKEN Center for Life Science Technologies, along with researchers from the AIST Human Technology Research Institute in Japan, have identified a time-dependent interplay between two brain ...
Recommended for you
New findings reveal genetic brain disorders converge at the synapse
24 minutes ago
Several genetic disorders cause intellectual disability and autism. Historically, these genetic brain diseases were viewed as untreatable. However, in recent years neuroscientists have shown in animal models ...
People watching: Different brain pathways responsible for person, movement recognition
16 hours ago
Each time you see a person that you know, your brain seemingly effortlessly and immediately recognizes that person by his or her face and body. Just as easily, your brain understands a person's movements, ...
Experience of pain relies on multiple brain pathways, not just one
18 hours ago
People's mindsets can affect their experience of pain. For example, a soldier in battle or an athlete in competition may report that an injury did not feel especially painful in the heat of the moment. But ...
Imaging study finds first evidence of neuroinflammation in brains of chronic pain patients
19 hours ago
A new study from Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) investigators has found, for the first time, evidence of neuroinflammation in key regions of the brains of patients with chronic pain. By showing that ...
New research on what the nose 'knows' reveals an unexpected simplicity
20 hours ago
What the nose knows is quite amazing, when you think about it. The moment you encounter an awful odor - spoiled milk, say, or the scent of skunk - you reflexively recoil in disgust. Often, too, you take action, ...
Mortality risks after carotid artery stenting in medicare beneficiaries
20 hours ago
Medicare beneficiaries who underwent carotid artery stenting (CAS) had a 32 percent mortality rate during an average two-year follow-up, suggesting the benefits of CAS may be limited for some patients, according to a study ...
User comments
Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more
Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.
© Medical Xpress 2011-2014, Science X network
by Scott Schrage
his functional MRI visualization shows how many of 12 tasks yielded differences in neural activity when study participants gave incorrect versus correct answers, from all 12 (red) to none (black). Credit: UNL Center for Brain, Biology and Behavior
Everyone makes mistakes—so a University of Nebraska-Lincoln psychologist set out to determine how the human brain responds to the errors of its ways.
"The reason to focus on errors is that they're a really pervasive part of our cognition," said Maital Neta, assistant professor of psychology. "They happen in everything that we do, even the simplest tasks. So if you want to get a sense for how something is structured in the brain—regardless of a specific mood or a specific task—then errors are a really good way to do it."
Neta and several colleagues recently published a study showing that even basic errors can trigger neural activity across a much broader swath of the brain than previously thought.
The authors performed functional MRI scans of study participants as they completed 12 diverse tasks that included recognizing parts of speech and mentally rotating three-dimensional shapes to identify matching pairs.
The team found that 41 regions of the brain showed substantial differences in activity following incorrect vs. correct answers on a majority of the tasks.
"Many people in the field of neuroscience have said that there's one primary region of the brain that responds to errors," Neta said. "One of the most interesting aspects of this paper is how it shows that even though that region may be really important, it's not the only one."
The fMRI scans also illustrated that the 41 regions are distributed across several networks of the brain that are otherwise distinguished by differing functions, Neta said.
In addition to analyzing the spatial aspects of error-related activity, the team measured the speed and duration of each region's activation. The researchers subsequently characterized three profiles of neural response: fast, prolonged and delayed. According to Neta, the study revealed that all but one of the brain's networks feature just a single response profile.
Neta's team further discovered that regions of the brain with the same error-related responses also exhibit similar activation patterns while at rest. Even regions residing in separate networks and sides of the brain seem to spontaneously function together when not occupied with an error or task, she said.
"This came out much more clearly than I would have ever expected," Neta said. "It makes a lot of intuitive sense—it's just that most results don't come out quite so perfectly.
"So there's something about this wiring or connectivity that works not only when you're at rest, but also when you're suddenly thrown into a situation that (might produce) an error. There's still a lot we don't know about the brain."
Though Neta's team focused on documenting and cataloging error-related activity, she noted that other researchers could use the study as a starting point for delving into specific linkages between regions and error-related reactions.
"Identifying all these regions is just sort of the first step," Neta said. "People whose research focuses on specifics of error processing could now look at different tasks individually and determine what these regions might be doing."
The study appeared in the Jan. 7 edition of The Journal of Neuroscience.
Explore further: Study finds which brain skills are more likely to last over a lifetime
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Study of brain activity in monkeys shows how the brain processes mistakes made by others
Jan 11, 2013
Humans and other animals learn by making mistakes. They can also learn from observing the mistakes of others. The brain processes self-generated errors in a region called the medial frontal cortex (MFC) but ...
Study finds which brain skills are more likely to last over a lifetime
Jan 09, 2015
Research from the Center for Vital Longevity (CVL) at The University of Texas at Dallas has shed new light on which cognitive processes tend to be preserved with age and which ones decline.
Human brain keeps memories tidy by pruning inaccurate ones
Jan 09, 2015
Forget about it. Your brain is a memory powerhouse, constantly recording experiences in long-term memory. Those memories help you find your way through the world: Who works the counter each morning at your ...
Dyslexic readers have disrupted network connections in the brain
Aug 28, 2014
Dyslexia, the most commonly diagnosed learning disability in the United States, is a neurological reading disability that occurs when the regions of the brain that process written language don't function normally.
Remapping the damaged brain
Jan 06, 2015
Scientists at the RIKEN Center for Life Science Technologies, along with researchers from the AIST Human Technology Research Institute in Japan, have identified a time-dependent interplay between two brain ...
Recommended for you
New findings reveal genetic brain disorders converge at the synapse
24 minutes ago
Several genetic disorders cause intellectual disability and autism. Historically, these genetic brain diseases were viewed as untreatable. However, in recent years neuroscientists have shown in animal models ...
People watching: Different brain pathways responsible for person, movement recognition
16 hours ago
Each time you see a person that you know, your brain seemingly effortlessly and immediately recognizes that person by his or her face and body. Just as easily, your brain understands a person's movements, ...
Experience of pain relies on multiple brain pathways, not just one
18 hours ago
People's mindsets can affect their experience of pain. For example, a soldier in battle or an athlete in competition may report that an injury did not feel especially painful in the heat of the moment. But ...
Imaging study finds first evidence of neuroinflammation in brains of chronic pain patients
19 hours ago
A new study from Massachusetts General Hospital (MGH) investigators has found, for the first time, evidence of neuroinflammation in key regions of the brains of patients with chronic pain. By showing that ...
New research on what the nose 'knows' reveals an unexpected simplicity
20 hours ago
What the nose knows is quite amazing, when you think about it. The moment you encounter an awful odor - spoiled milk, say, or the scent of skunk - you reflexively recoil in disgust. Often, too, you take action, ...
Mortality risks after carotid artery stenting in medicare beneficiaries
20 hours ago
Medicare beneficiaries who underwent carotid artery stenting (CAS) had a 32 percent mortality rate during an average two-year follow-up, suggesting the benefits of CAS may be limited for some patients, according to a study ...
User comments
Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more
Click here
to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.
© Medical Xpress 2011-2014, Science X network
0 comments:
Post a Comment