Many hospital trusts in England and Wales are falling short of the recommended standards on obtaining consent for a post mortem, indicates a snapshot survey of practice published online in the Journal of Clinical Pathology.
Active informed consent became a key tenet of post mortem exam procedures following the organ retention scandals at Bristol Royal Infirmary and The Royal Liverpool Children's Hospital, which prompted the enactment of the 2004 Human Tissue Act.
The Act stipulates that consent must be actively sought from either the individual while alive, or when this is not possible, from a nominated representative or close family member. Breaches of the law attract a prison sentence and a fine.
The authors obtained staff policies on post mortem procedures from 26 hospital trusts in England and Wales. They compared the content with guidelines set out by the regulator in this area, the Human Tissue Authority (HTA).
They focused particularly on whether the policies explained: the law behind consent to post mortem; the consent process; which staff members should take consent; and training requirements for consent takers.
The HTA guidance states that every hospital should provide staff with a documented consent procedure, and have relevant experience and understanding of the procedures involved.
The guidance also says that staff should be trained in dealing with bereavement and have witnessed a post mortem themselves, and specifies that responsibility for obtaining consent "should not be delegated to untrained or inexperienced staff."
Out of the 26 post mortem policies scrutinised, one failed to explain the legislation governing consent to a post mortem; more than one in 10 (12%) of policies did not outline a clear process for how consent for the procedure should be obtained.
Furthermore, 12% of policies did not specify which staff members should take consent for a post mortem, and almost one in four (23%) of policies failed to state the training requirements of those responsible.
One in three (35%) trusts did not stipulate any requirements for the consent taker to be sufficiently experienced; over half of trusts (58%) did not specify that consent takers needed to be trained in bereavement; and over two thirds (69%) did not recommend that consent takers should have witnessed a post mortem.
Some 12% of policies failed to outline the consent process in full, including failing to describe when families should first be approached, or which staff members should talk to families before they are presented with a consent form.
"Given the sensitive nature of consent discussions, it is vital that the process is conducted in an appropriate manner," write the authors. Adequate and clear guidance for this is therefore essential they add, highlighting "the significant shortcomings" their analysis revealed.
They point out that hospital post mortem rates have been falling steadily, despite the importance of the procedure in understanding disease and enhancing medical education. And a clumsy, poorly informed approach to families when a loved one has just died is unlikely to reverse that trend.
The authors acknowledge that policies do not necessarily reflect actual practice, and some of the trust policies may also have subsequently changed.
But they emphasise that in the current climate of financial cutbacks, "it would be feasible for trusts to see [post mortems] as an easy target to limit investment to the detriment of the medical profession. Hence it is vital for the HTA to uphold standards and continue to ensure that the consent process is always carried out in a satisfactory manner for all concerned."
Explore further: ATS publishes statement on organ donation after circulatory determination of death
More information: Paper: www.jcp.bmj.com/lookup/doi/10.1136/jclinpath-2013-201869
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Specialist nurses boost parental willingness to consent to post-mortem research on children
Mar 12, 2009
Parents are mostly willing to consent to post mortem research on their children, providing they are approached by specialist nurses, experienced in bereavement and family counselling, suggests a small study published ahead ...
ATS publishes statement on organ donation after circulatory determination of death
Jul 01, 2013
The American Thoracic Society has released an official statement on the ethical and health policy considerations surrounding adult and pediatric controlled organ donation after circulatory determination of death (DCDD), the ...
Is informed consent threatening biobank research?
Oct 05, 2011
Having to obtain informed consent for the use of left-over human tissue samples could be hampering essential biobank research says a research group on BMJ.com today.
Parents don't fully understand biobank research, study finds
Jul 29, 2013
Researchers who collect genetic samples from children for medical research need to explain the process more clearly to parents, according to a new study that suggests many parents don't fully understand the finer details ...
Survey suggests that informed consent process important to surgery patients in teaching hospital
Sep 19, 2011
A survey of patients receiving treatment in a teaching facility found that patients prefer to be informed of trainee participation in their care, and consent rates appear to vary based on scenarios describing increased levels ...
Recommended for you
Boomers' embrace of devices gives rise to new med-tech age
10 minutes ago
Jay Alva's sneakers pounded the treadmill, set to the speed of a brisk walk. Sweat dripped off the 53-year-old as he hit a groove during a recent workout.
Be nice to your bacteria and they'll be nice to you, doctors say
1 hour ago
At 60, Marty Wichter of Arlington, Texas, found himself in constant digestive distress and at a loss for what to do.
World Bank sets $700 mn for women's, children's health
1 hour ago
World Bank President Jim Yong Kim announced Monday that at least $700 million would be made available over the next two years for women's and children's health needs in poor countries.
Racial and ethnic disparities exist in ER pain management for children with abdominal pain
1 hour ago
Pediatric researchers have found race- and ethnicity-based disparities in pain management and length of stay among children who came to hospital emergency departments for treatment of abdominal pain. A study team reported ...
Medicare expenses for patients with heart attacks increase between 1998 and 2008
2 hours ago
Medicare expenses for patients with acute myocardial infarction (AMI, heart attack) increased substantially between 1998 and 2008, with much of the increase coming in expenses 31 days or more after the patient was hospitalized, ...
Team finds daytime naps enhance learning in preschool children
3 hours ago
Sleep researchers at the University of Massachusetts Amherst today offer the first research results showing that classroom naps support learning in preschool children by enhancing memory. Children who napped performed significantly ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
Many hospital trusts in England and Wales are falling short of the recommended standards on obtaining consent for a post mortem, indicates a snapshot survey of practice published online in the Journal of Clinical Pathology.
Active informed consent became a key tenet of post mortem exam procedures following the organ retention scandals at Bristol Royal Infirmary and The Royal Liverpool Children's Hospital, which prompted the enactment of the 2004 Human Tissue Act.
The Act stipulates that consent must be actively sought from either the individual while alive, or when this is not possible, from a nominated representative or close family member. Breaches of the law attract a prison sentence and a fine.
The authors obtained staff policies on post mortem procedures from 26 hospital trusts in England and Wales. They compared the content with guidelines set out by the regulator in this area, the Human Tissue Authority (HTA).
They focused particularly on whether the policies explained: the law behind consent to post mortem; the consent process; which staff members should take consent; and training requirements for consent takers.
The HTA guidance states that every hospital should provide staff with a documented consent procedure, and have relevant experience and understanding of the procedures involved.
The guidance also says that staff should be trained in dealing with bereavement and have witnessed a post mortem themselves, and specifies that responsibility for obtaining consent "should not be delegated to untrained or inexperienced staff."
Out of the 26 post mortem policies scrutinised, one failed to explain the legislation governing consent to a post mortem; more than one in 10 (12%) of policies did not outline a clear process for how consent for the procedure should be obtained.
Furthermore, 12% of policies did not specify which staff members should take consent for a post mortem, and almost one in four (23%) of policies failed to state the training requirements of those responsible.
One in three (35%) trusts did not stipulate any requirements for the consent taker to be sufficiently experienced; over half of trusts (58%) did not specify that consent takers needed to be trained in bereavement; and over two thirds (69%) did not recommend that consent takers should have witnessed a post mortem.
Some 12% of policies failed to outline the consent process in full, including failing to describe when families should first be approached, or which staff members should talk to families before they are presented with a consent form.
"Given the sensitive nature of consent discussions, it is vital that the process is conducted in an appropriate manner," write the authors. Adequate and clear guidance for this is therefore essential they add, highlighting "the significant shortcomings" their analysis revealed.
They point out that hospital post mortem rates have been falling steadily, despite the importance of the procedure in understanding disease and enhancing medical education. And a clumsy, poorly informed approach to families when a loved one has just died is unlikely to reverse that trend.
The authors acknowledge that policies do not necessarily reflect actual practice, and some of the trust policies may also have subsequently changed.
But they emphasise that in the current climate of financial cutbacks, "it would be feasible for trusts to see [post mortems] as an easy target to limit investment to the detriment of the medical profession. Hence it is vital for the HTA to uphold standards and continue to ensure that the consent process is always carried out in a satisfactory manner for all concerned."
Explore further: ATS publishes statement on organ donation after circulatory determination of death
More information: Paper: www.jcp.bmj.com/lookup/doi/10.1136/jclinpath-2013-201869
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Specialist nurses boost parental willingness to consent to post-mortem research on children
Mar 12, 2009
Parents are mostly willing to consent to post mortem research on their children, providing they are approached by specialist nurses, experienced in bereavement and family counselling, suggests a small study published ahead ...
ATS publishes statement on organ donation after circulatory determination of death
Jul 01, 2013
The American Thoracic Society has released an official statement on the ethical and health policy considerations surrounding adult and pediatric controlled organ donation after circulatory determination of death (DCDD), the ...
Is informed consent threatening biobank research?
Oct 05, 2011
Having to obtain informed consent for the use of left-over human tissue samples could be hampering essential biobank research says a research group on BMJ.com today.
Parents don't fully understand biobank research, study finds
Jul 29, 2013
Researchers who collect genetic samples from children for medical research need to explain the process more clearly to parents, according to a new study that suggests many parents don't fully understand the finer details ...
Survey suggests that informed consent process important to surgery patients in teaching hospital
Sep 19, 2011
A survey of patients receiving treatment in a teaching facility found that patients prefer to be informed of trainee participation in their care, and consent rates appear to vary based on scenarios describing increased levels ...
Recommended for you
Boomers' embrace of devices gives rise to new med-tech age
10 minutes ago
Jay Alva's sneakers pounded the treadmill, set to the speed of a brisk walk. Sweat dripped off the 53-year-old as he hit a groove during a recent workout.
Be nice to your bacteria and they'll be nice to you, doctors say
1 hour ago
At 60, Marty Wichter of Arlington, Texas, found himself in constant digestive distress and at a loss for what to do.
World Bank sets $700 mn for women's, children's health
1 hour ago
World Bank President Jim Yong Kim announced Monday that at least $700 million would be made available over the next two years for women's and children's health needs in poor countries.
Racial and ethnic disparities exist in ER pain management for children with abdominal pain
1 hour ago
Pediatric researchers have found race- and ethnicity-based disparities in pain management and length of stay among children who came to hospital emergency departments for treatment of abdominal pain. A study team reported ...
Medicare expenses for patients with heart attacks increase between 1998 and 2008
2 hours ago
Medicare expenses for patients with acute myocardial infarction (AMI, heart attack) increased substantially between 1998 and 2008, with much of the increase coming in expenses 31 days or more after the patient was hospitalized, ...
Team finds daytime naps enhance learning in preschool children
3 hours ago
Sleep researchers at the University of Massachusetts Amherst today offer the first research results showing that classroom naps support learning in preschool children by enhancing memory. Children who napped performed significantly ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
0 comments:
Post a Comment