An Australian first study has revealed GPs are unlikely to recommend injured workers take alternative duties.
Victorian General Practitioners (GPs) are more likely to order ill or injured workers stay away from work than recommend alternative duties, according to an Australian first study.
Published in the prestigious Medical Journal of Australia this week, the study examined more than 120,000 medical certificates provided to injured workers in Victoria from 2003 to 2010.
The study was a collaborative work undertaken by academics from the Institute for Safety, Compensation and Recovery Research (ISCRR) and Monash University's Department of Epidemiology and Preventative Medicine.
Chief Research Officer for ISCRR, Dr Alex Collie, said more than 70 per cent of initial medical certificates issued by GPs for injured workers instructed them to stay away from work. Fewer than a quarter recommended a return to work with modified duties.
"This has significant implications given the growing body of evidence showing work benefits health and that returning to work after injury or illness can in fact promote recovery," Dr Collie said.
"These days lost are also highly relevant to the growing debate around the productivity of our workforce and the viability of compensation schemes.
"We know that GPs play a front line role in returning injured workers to work as they are the first point of contact with the health care system and the main gatekeepers to works compensation and disability benefits."
The study is the first to assess sickness certification of injured and ill workers in Australia and the first study worldwide to assess certification by GPs in a population this large.
It also found GPs were more likely to issue unfit-for-work certificates for patients with mental health conditions.
"Our results are consistent with studies in the UK which showed the highest proportion of unfit-for-work certificates were written for workers with mental health conditions," Dr Collie said.
Only four per cent of Victorian workers with mental health conditions received a certificate recommending a return to work with modified duties in this study.
"Workers with fractures, traumatic injuries, back pain and strains, musculoskeletal disorders and other diseases were more likely to receive certificates recommending a return to work than those with mental health conditions," Dr Collie said.
The study is part of a broader project examining the role of GPs in the return to work process and has undertaken in-depth qualitative interviews with GPs, injured workers, employers and compensation scheme representatives.
Lead researcher Professor Danielle Mazza, from Monash University, said the one-on-one interviews provided a detailed cross-section of viewpoints.
"The interviews explored the intricacies of the individuals' experience from their perspective and this will in turn facilitate understanding of the attitudes and practices of the various groups involved in returning an injured or ill worker to work," Professor Mazza said.
Explore further: The experiences of injured persons in compensation systems
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
The experiences of injured persons in compensation systems
Sep 18, 2013
The findings of three studies offering important insights into compensation systems and injured people will be presented at a research symposium in Melbourne this week.
Workers make fewer claims for psychological illnesses
Aug 23, 2012
Research has found that Australian workers are significantly less likely to claim GP visits for psychological illnesses on workers' compensation than they are for physical work-related injuries like musculoskeletal disorders.
White construction workers in Illinois get higher workers' comp settlements, study finds
Oct 12, 2012
White non-Hispanic construction workers are awarded higher workers' compensation settlements in Illinois than Hispanic or black construction workers with similar injuries and disabilities, according to researchers at the ...
Precarious employment on the rise
22 hours ago
Ontario's economy, and its traditional economic stronghold in the Toronto region, are slowly returning to pre-recessionary levels of employment. Yet there has been growing concern about the kinds of jobs the economy is creating. ...
Hairdressers reluctant to claim workers comp, study finds
Dec 12, 2012
A large number of hairdressers do not claim workers compensation for occupational contact dermatitis, according to a recent study.
Recommended for you
EU lawmakers to push ahead with anti-tobacco plans (Update)
2 hours ago
European lawmakers on Tuesday were set to tighten rules governing the multibillion-dollar tobacco market by imposing bigger and bolder warnings on cigarette packs, banning most flavorings like menthol and strengthening regulation ...
Evaluating mobile weight loss apps on use of evidence-based behavioral strategies
6 hours ago
In a new study published by the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, UMass Medical School behavioral psychologist and weight loss expert Sherry Pagoto, PhD, and colleagues find that mobile apps to help people lose weight ...
New study shows link between car crashes and adverse pregnancy outcomes
6 hours ago
A new study published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine indicates that motor vehicle crashes can be hazardous for pregnant women, especially if they are not wearing a seat belt when the accident occurs.
Just five in every 1,000 NHS doctors prompt performance concerns each year
12 hours ago
less than 1% of the workforce—prompt concerns about their performance every year, sufficient to warrant the need for outside help, indicates an analysis of 11 years of data, published in BMJ Quality & Safety.
Death rates higher among middle aged and elderly when economy is booming
12 hours ago
Death rates among middle aged and older people are higher when the economy is growing than when it's heading for recession, reveals a long term analysis of the economic cycles of developed countries, published online in the ...
Design and software problems plague health exchanges
13 hours ago
(HealthDay)—Problems signing up for health insurance through HealthCare.gov, the federal website serving health exchanges in 36 states, are the result of design and software problems, The Wall Street Jo ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
An Australian first study has revealed GPs are unlikely to recommend injured workers take alternative duties.
Victorian General Practitioners (GPs) are more likely to order ill or injured workers stay away from work than recommend alternative duties, according to an Australian first study.
Published in the prestigious Medical Journal of Australia this week, the study examined more than 120,000 medical certificates provided to injured workers in Victoria from 2003 to 2010.
The study was a collaborative work undertaken by academics from the Institute for Safety, Compensation and Recovery Research (ISCRR) and Monash University's Department of Epidemiology and Preventative Medicine.
Chief Research Officer for ISCRR, Dr Alex Collie, said more than 70 per cent of initial medical certificates issued by GPs for injured workers instructed them to stay away from work. Fewer than a quarter recommended a return to work with modified duties.
"This has significant implications given the growing body of evidence showing work benefits health and that returning to work after injury or illness can in fact promote recovery," Dr Collie said.
"These days lost are also highly relevant to the growing debate around the productivity of our workforce and the viability of compensation schemes.
"We know that GPs play a front line role in returning injured workers to work as they are the first point of contact with the health care system and the main gatekeepers to works compensation and disability benefits."
The study is the first to assess sickness certification of injured and ill workers in Australia and the first study worldwide to assess certification by GPs in a population this large.
It also found GPs were more likely to issue unfit-for-work certificates for patients with mental health conditions.
"Our results are consistent with studies in the UK which showed the highest proportion of unfit-for-work certificates were written for workers with mental health conditions," Dr Collie said.
Only four per cent of Victorian workers with mental health conditions received a certificate recommending a return to work with modified duties in this study.
"Workers with fractures, traumatic injuries, back pain and strains, musculoskeletal disorders and other diseases were more likely to receive certificates recommending a return to work than those with mental health conditions," Dr Collie said.
The study is part of a broader project examining the role of GPs in the return to work process and has undertaken in-depth qualitative interviews with GPs, injured workers, employers and compensation scheme representatives.
Lead researcher Professor Danielle Mazza, from Monash University, said the one-on-one interviews provided a detailed cross-section of viewpoints.
"The interviews explored the intricacies of the individuals' experience from their perspective and this will in turn facilitate understanding of the attitudes and practices of the various groups involved in returning an injured or ill worker to work," Professor Mazza said.
Explore further: The experiences of injured persons in compensation systems
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
The experiences of injured persons in compensation systems
Sep 18, 2013
The findings of three studies offering important insights into compensation systems and injured people will be presented at a research symposium in Melbourne this week.
Workers make fewer claims for psychological illnesses
Aug 23, 2012
Research has found that Australian workers are significantly less likely to claim GP visits for psychological illnesses on workers' compensation than they are for physical work-related injuries like musculoskeletal disorders.
White construction workers in Illinois get higher workers' comp settlements, study finds
Oct 12, 2012
White non-Hispanic construction workers are awarded higher workers' compensation settlements in Illinois than Hispanic or black construction workers with similar injuries and disabilities, according to researchers at the ...
Precarious employment on the rise
22 hours ago
Ontario's economy, and its traditional economic stronghold in the Toronto region, are slowly returning to pre-recessionary levels of employment. Yet there has been growing concern about the kinds of jobs the economy is creating. ...
Hairdressers reluctant to claim workers comp, study finds
Dec 12, 2012
A large number of hairdressers do not claim workers compensation for occupational contact dermatitis, according to a recent study.
Recommended for you
EU lawmakers to push ahead with anti-tobacco plans (Update)
2 hours ago
European lawmakers on Tuesday were set to tighten rules governing the multibillion-dollar tobacco market by imposing bigger and bolder warnings on cigarette packs, banning most flavorings like menthol and strengthening regulation ...
Evaluating mobile weight loss apps on use of evidence-based behavioral strategies
6 hours ago
In a new study published by the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, UMass Medical School behavioral psychologist and weight loss expert Sherry Pagoto, PhD, and colleagues find that mobile apps to help people lose weight ...
New study shows link between car crashes and adverse pregnancy outcomes
6 hours ago
A new study published in the American Journal of Preventive Medicine indicates that motor vehicle crashes can be hazardous for pregnant women, especially if they are not wearing a seat belt when the accident occurs.
Just five in every 1,000 NHS doctors prompt performance concerns each year
12 hours ago
less than 1% of the workforce—prompt concerns about their performance every year, sufficient to warrant the need for outside help, indicates an analysis of 11 years of data, published in BMJ Quality & Safety.
Death rates higher among middle aged and elderly when economy is booming
12 hours ago
Death rates among middle aged and older people are higher when the economy is growing than when it's heading for recession, reveals a long term analysis of the economic cycles of developed countries, published online in the ...
Design and software problems plague health exchanges
13 hours ago
(HealthDay)—Problems signing up for health insurance through HealthCare.gov, the federal website serving health exchanges in 36 states, are the result of design and software problems, The Wall Street Jo ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
0 comments:
Post a Comment