by Jennie Matthew
Victims of a Haiti cholera epidemic Wednesday filed a lawsuit demanding compensation from the United Nations over an outbreak that killed more than 8,300 people.
The petition filed at the New York district court said at least 679,000 other people had fallen ill with cholera since the outbreak began in October 2010.
There had been no cholera in Haiti for at least 150 years until it was brought by UN peacekeeping troops from Nepal, lawyer Ira Kurzban told a news conference.
The United Nations, which refused to reach an out-of-court compensation settlement, said in February it was legally immune from action over the epidemic.
On Wednesday, a UN spokesman, Farhan Haq, said of the lawsuit: "The UN remains committed to do all it can to help the people of Haiti overcome the cholera epidemic.
"It is not UN practice to discuss in public claims filed against the organization."
"Our comments from previous months stand."
The source of the cholera epidemic was traced to a river that runs next to a UN camp in the central town of Mirebalais, where Nepalese troops had been based.
The strain of cholera the deeply impoverished Caribbean nation is the same as one endemic in Nepal.
"The outbreak resulted from the negligent, reckless, and tortious conduct of the defendants," said a copy of the petition seen by AFP.
It lists the defendants as the United Nations, the UN Stabilization Mission in Haiti and at least two of their officers.
"We feel in this lawsuit we're going to win," Kurzban told reporters.
"This is a unique set of circumstances for which the United Nations cannot behind the shield of immunity."
The US-based Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti (IJDH), which is representing 8,000 victims and families of those who died, says cholera continues to kill about 1,000 Haitians a year.
In May, the victims gave the United Nations a 60-day deadline to reach a compensation deal or face a lawsuit.
Lawyers at the time sought $100,000 for the family of each victim who died and $50,000 for each survivor, which could take the claim into several billion dollars.
On Wednesday IJDH spokeswoman Beatrice Lindstrom told reporters it would up to the jury to set the limits of the compensation figure in court.
The epidemic dealt a new blow to Haiti as it struggled to overcome the strife caused by a January 2010 earthquake that killed 250,000 people.
The UN said in February that the complaint from victims' lawyers was "non-receivable" under a 1946 convention setting out the UN's immunities for its actions.
In December, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon launched a $2.2 billion appeal, however, to raise money to provide clean water and health facilities in Haiti.
Kurzban accused the United Nations of stonewalling and said it had failed to meet fundraising goals on efforts to provide clean water and proper sanitation in Haiti.
He said lawyers would fight to the end and appeal if the New York district court dismisses the case.
"We're certainly going to continue to fight this case. We believe very strongly in the principles of accountability for the United Nations," he said.
The lawsuit has been filed in New York as the city where the United Nations is headquartered. New York also has a substantial Haitian community.
The petition said the Haiti epidemic had also resulted in additional cholera cases in Cuba, the Dominican Republic and the United States, at least.
Explore further: UN chief tells US it will combat cholera in Haiti
© 2013 AFP
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
UN chief tells US it will combat cholera in Haiti
Jul 06, 2013
Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon told members of the U.S. Congress Friday that the United Nations is committed to helping Haiti overcome a cholera epidemic even though it is refusing to pay compensation to victims who blame ...
UN rejects Haiti cholera damages claim
Feb 21, 2013
The United Nations on Thursday formally rejected a multi-billion-dollar damages claim for a cholera epidemic in Haiti that has been widely blamed on UN peacekeepers.
UN chief names special advisor for Haiti cholera
Dec 29, 2012
The UN chief on Friday named a US health expert as special advisor in fighting Haiti's cholera epidemic, which has claimed more than 7,750 lives and is widely blamed on UN peacekeepers.
Study: UN should be accountable for Haiti cholera (Update)
Aug 06, 2013
The United Nations peacekeeping mission in Haiti should be held accountable for introducing cholera into the Caribbean nation, a Yale University report said Tuesday.
UN launches major cholera appeal for Haiti
Dec 12, 2012
The United Nations on Tuesday launched a $2.2 billion appeal for a campaign to halt a cholera epidemic in Haiti, widely blamed on UN peacekeepers, which has killed more than 7,750 people.
Recommended for you
BUSM identifies barriers to implementing complimentary medicine curricula into residency
1 hour ago
Investigators at Boston University School of Medicine (BUSM) have identified that lack of time and a paucity of trained faculty are perceived as the most significant barriers to incorporating complementary and alternative ...
Marilyn Monroe plastic surgery files to be sold
9 hours ago
Medical files proving that screen icon Marilyn Monroe underwent cosmetic surgery including on her nose and chin are to be sold at auction next month, auctioneers said Tuesday.
Clinical trial outcomes more complete in unpublished reports than published sources
20 hours ago
Clinical trial outcomes are more complete in unpublished reports than in publicly available information
Black medical students in US have heaviest debts, study finds
Oct 08, 2013
(HealthDay)—Black medical school students are more likely to be saddled with large education-related debts than students from other racial or ethnic groups, and this discrepancy may help explain the declining ...
Drive behind Nobel Medicine Prize say winners
Oct 07, 2013
A German-born neuroscientist who describes himself as "incredibly driven" was actually driving around in Spain when his phone rang Monday with the news that he'd won the Nobel Prize. ...
Improving the quality of clinical ethics consultants
Oct 07, 2013
Clinical ethicists play a vital role in hospitals and other health care systems by helping to resolve ethical conflicts that arise between patients, families, and clinicians about end-of-life care and other important medical ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
by Jennie Matthew
Victims of a Haiti cholera epidemic Wednesday filed a lawsuit demanding compensation from the United Nations over an outbreak that killed more than 8,300 people.
The petition filed at the New York district court said at least 679,000 other people had fallen ill with cholera since the outbreak began in October 2010.
There had been no cholera in Haiti for at least 150 years until it was brought by UN peacekeeping troops from Nepal, lawyer Ira Kurzban told a news conference.
The United Nations, which refused to reach an out-of-court compensation settlement, said in February it was legally immune from action over the epidemic.
On Wednesday, a UN spokesman, Farhan Haq, said of the lawsuit: "The UN remains committed to do all it can to help the people of Haiti overcome the cholera epidemic.
"It is not UN practice to discuss in public claims filed against the organization."
"Our comments from previous months stand."
The source of the cholera epidemic was traced to a river that runs next to a UN camp in the central town of Mirebalais, where Nepalese troops had been based.
The strain of cholera the deeply impoverished Caribbean nation is the same as one endemic in Nepal.
"The outbreak resulted from the negligent, reckless, and tortious conduct of the defendants," said a copy of the petition seen by AFP.
It lists the defendants as the United Nations, the UN Stabilization Mission in Haiti and at least two of their officers.
"We feel in this lawsuit we're going to win," Kurzban told reporters.
"This is a unique set of circumstances for which the United Nations cannot behind the shield of immunity."
The US-based Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti (IJDH), which is representing 8,000 victims and families of those who died, says cholera continues to kill about 1,000 Haitians a year.
In May, the victims gave the United Nations a 60-day deadline to reach a compensation deal or face a lawsuit.
Lawyers at the time sought $100,000 for the family of each victim who died and $50,000 for each survivor, which could take the claim into several billion dollars.
On Wednesday IJDH spokeswoman Beatrice Lindstrom told reporters it would up to the jury to set the limits of the compensation figure in court.
The epidemic dealt a new blow to Haiti as it struggled to overcome the strife caused by a January 2010 earthquake that killed 250,000 people.
The UN said in February that the complaint from victims' lawyers was "non-receivable" under a 1946 convention setting out the UN's immunities for its actions.
In December, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon launched a $2.2 billion appeal, however, to raise money to provide clean water and health facilities in Haiti.
Kurzban accused the United Nations of stonewalling and said it had failed to meet fundraising goals on efforts to provide clean water and proper sanitation in Haiti.
He said lawyers would fight to the end and appeal if the New York district court dismisses the case.
"We're certainly going to continue to fight this case. We believe very strongly in the principles of accountability for the United Nations," he said.
The lawsuit has been filed in New York as the city where the United Nations is headquartered. New York also has a substantial Haitian community.
The petition said the Haiti epidemic had also resulted in additional cholera cases in Cuba, the Dominican Republic and the United States, at least.
Explore further: UN chief tells US it will combat cholera in Haiti
© 2013 AFP
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
UN chief tells US it will combat cholera in Haiti
Jul 06, 2013
Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon told members of the U.S. Congress Friday that the United Nations is committed to helping Haiti overcome a cholera epidemic even though it is refusing to pay compensation to victims who blame ...
UN rejects Haiti cholera damages claim
Feb 21, 2013
The United Nations on Thursday formally rejected a multi-billion-dollar damages claim for a cholera epidemic in Haiti that has been widely blamed on UN peacekeepers.
UN chief names special advisor for Haiti cholera
Dec 29, 2012
The UN chief on Friday named a US health expert as special advisor in fighting Haiti's cholera epidemic, which has claimed more than 7,750 lives and is widely blamed on UN peacekeepers.
Study: UN should be accountable for Haiti cholera (Update)
Aug 06, 2013
The United Nations peacekeeping mission in Haiti should be held accountable for introducing cholera into the Caribbean nation, a Yale University report said Tuesday.
UN launches major cholera appeal for Haiti
Dec 12, 2012
The United Nations on Tuesday launched a $2.2 billion appeal for a campaign to halt a cholera epidemic in Haiti, widely blamed on UN peacekeepers, which has killed more than 7,750 people.
Recommended for you
BUSM identifies barriers to implementing complimentary medicine curricula into residency
1 hour ago
Investigators at Boston University School of Medicine (BUSM) have identified that lack of time and a paucity of trained faculty are perceived as the most significant barriers to incorporating complementary and alternative ...
Marilyn Monroe plastic surgery files to be sold
9 hours ago
Medical files proving that screen icon Marilyn Monroe underwent cosmetic surgery including on her nose and chin are to be sold at auction next month, auctioneers said Tuesday.
Clinical trial outcomes more complete in unpublished reports than published sources
20 hours ago
Clinical trial outcomes are more complete in unpublished reports than in publicly available information
Black medical students in US have heaviest debts, study finds
Oct 08, 2013
(HealthDay)—Black medical school students are more likely to be saddled with large education-related debts than students from other racial or ethnic groups, and this discrepancy may help explain the declining ...
Drive behind Nobel Medicine Prize say winners
Oct 07, 2013
A German-born neuroscientist who describes himself as "incredibly driven" was actually driving around in Spain when his phone rang Monday with the news that he'd won the Nobel Prize. ...
Improving the quality of clinical ethics consultants
Oct 07, 2013
Clinical ethicists play a vital role in hospitals and other health care systems by helping to resolve ethical conflicts that arise between patients, families, and clinicians about end-of-life care and other important medical ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
0 comments:
Post a Comment