by Isabelle Knight & Reema Rattan, The Conversation
Editors of journals published by the BMJ Group will no longer consider publishing research that is partly or wholly funded by the tobacco industry, the journals have said in an editorial published this week.
Worldwide, tobacco use causes more than five million deaths every year, and current trends show that it will cause more than eight million deaths annually by the year 2030.
Editor-in-chief of BMJ Open Trish Groves said editors of the BMJ, BMJ Open, Heart, and Thorax could no longer "ignore the growing body of evidence – from the tobacco industry's released internal documents – that the industry continues to actively play down the risks of its products."
"What's worse is that scientific journals have published potentially biased studies that were funded by industry, often without realising that research funding bodies that sounded independent and academic were largely paid for by industry."
Other journals that have previously introduced such bans include PLOS Medicine in 2010 and the journals published by The American Thoracic Society in 1995.
The journals' policy change comes in the wake of a recent scandal involving Phillip Morris in the United Kingdom where the government was considering mandating standard packaging for tobacco products.
Leaked confidential documents showed the company was using a sophisticated lobbying campaign to target politicians and civil servants it believed would support its position against the move.
Professor of public health at Curtin University, Mike Daube said he had "huge respect" for the journals' decision.
"I think this is a really important step forward, it emphasises that medical journals should not be part of, or play any role in promoting tobacco companies and the tobacco industry."
Ethicist and professor of medicine at Monash University, Paul Komesaroff said the move raised questions about whether the ban should be extended to other industries.
"If this principle is adopted, a question then arises is how far further we take it, he said. "Clearly, there are other companies that are involved in activities that might be regarded as being contrary to public health."
Professor Mike Daube said there was a strong case for the journals to take a similar position with regard to the alcohol industry.
The journals have not ruled out banning research supported by other industries.
"We know already that other industries, such as 'Big Food' have followed suit in some of the ways they [the tobacco industry] lobby policymakers," Groves said. "If the evidence becomes strong enough that they have also distorted science, journal editors may consider similar bans on submissions of research funded by the food industry. But we're not there yet."
Explore further: Tobacco companies' interests in smokeless tobacco products in Europe are driven by profit not health
This story is published courtesy of The Conversation (under Creative Commons-Attribution/No derivatives).
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Another journal refuses tobacco-sponsored research
Feb 28, 2010
The online, open-access journal PLoS Medicine said this week that it will no longer accept for publication reports of research sponsored by tobacco companies. The journal joins two of its sister publications, PLoS Biology ...
Tobacco companies' interests in smokeless tobacco products in Europe are driven by profit not health
Sep 10, 2013
Transnational tobacco companies' investments in smokeless tobacco products, such as snus (a moist tobacco product that is placed under the upper lip), in Europe are not due to a concern for the health impacts of smoking but ...
Greater transparency needed in publishing information from clinical trials
Jan 29, 2013
An initiative from the drugs regulator, the European Medicines Agency, to commit to releasing all of the information from clinical trials once the marketing authorization process has ended, which has been greeted with cautious ...
WHO chief accuses tobacco giant of 'sabotaging' EU health bill
Sep 11, 2013
The World Health Organisation chief on Wednesday accused tobacco giant Philip Morris of seeking to "sabotage" a proposed EU measure to clamp down on tobacco industry marketing aimed at women and youngsters.
Harmful effects of ultra-processed food and drink industries should be regulated
Feb 11, 2013
An international analysis of food, drink, and alcohol industry involvement in NCD policies shows that despite the common reliance on industry self-regulation and public-private partnerships to improve public health, there ...
Recommended for you
Healthy food rarely convenient for urban minorities
30 minutes ago
Despite the prevalence of corner and convenience stores in urban neighborhoods, many residents have to travel farther to find supermarkets that offer a wide variety of healthful food choices, finds a new ...
Telecare could help care home residents get a better night's sleep
46 minutes ago
A study of sleep habits in care homes has found that staffing levels, shift patterns and safety checks can significantly affect residents' ability to get a good night's sleep.
Study finds nearly a third of Pittsburgh homicides might have been prevented
50 minutes ago
(Medical Xpress)—More than 30 percent of the homicides in Pittsburgh last year were likely related to peer violence, not gang activity, and are the type of crime most readily prevented by early intervention, according to ...
Eye contact builds bedside trust: Doctors who make eye contact seem more empathetic to patients
1 hour ago
(Medical Xpress)—Doctors who make a lot of eye contact are viewed as more likable and empathetic by patients, according to a new Northwestern Medicine® study.
Food waste, diets in focus on UN World Food Day
2 hours ago
The United Nations marked World Food Day on Wednesday, warning against food waste as 842 million people go hungry and stressing the importance of healthy diets amid rising obesity.
Positive results of Phase 3 trial of 1-year contraceptive vaginal ring presented
8 hours ago
Today, the Population Council presented findings from a Phase 3 clinical trial that was designed to demonstrate the safety, efficacy, and acceptability of the Council's investigational one-year contraceptive vaginal ring ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
by Isabelle Knight & Reema Rattan, The Conversation
Editors of journals published by the BMJ Group will no longer consider publishing research that is partly or wholly funded by the tobacco industry, the journals have said in an editorial published this week.
Worldwide, tobacco use causes more than five million deaths every year, and current trends show that it will cause more than eight million deaths annually by the year 2030.
Editor-in-chief of BMJ Open Trish Groves said editors of the BMJ, BMJ Open, Heart, and Thorax could no longer "ignore the growing body of evidence – from the tobacco industry's released internal documents – that the industry continues to actively play down the risks of its products."
"What's worse is that scientific journals have published potentially biased studies that were funded by industry, often without realising that research funding bodies that sounded independent and academic were largely paid for by industry."
Other journals that have previously introduced such bans include PLOS Medicine in 2010 and the journals published by The American Thoracic Society in 1995.
The journals' policy change comes in the wake of a recent scandal involving Phillip Morris in the United Kingdom where the government was considering mandating standard packaging for tobacco products.
Leaked confidential documents showed the company was using a sophisticated lobbying campaign to target politicians and civil servants it believed would support its position against the move.
Professor of public health at Curtin University, Mike Daube said he had "huge respect" for the journals' decision.
"I think this is a really important step forward, it emphasises that medical journals should not be part of, or play any role in promoting tobacco companies and the tobacco industry."
Ethicist and professor of medicine at Monash University, Paul Komesaroff said the move raised questions about whether the ban should be extended to other industries.
"If this principle is adopted, a question then arises is how far further we take it, he said. "Clearly, there are other companies that are involved in activities that might be regarded as being contrary to public health."
Professor Mike Daube said there was a strong case for the journals to take a similar position with regard to the alcohol industry.
The journals have not ruled out banning research supported by other industries.
"We know already that other industries, such as 'Big Food' have followed suit in some of the ways they [the tobacco industry] lobby policymakers," Groves said. "If the evidence becomes strong enough that they have also distorted science, journal editors may consider similar bans on submissions of research funded by the food industry. But we're not there yet."
Explore further: Tobacco companies' interests in smokeless tobacco products in Europe are driven by profit not health
This story is published courtesy of The Conversation (under Creative Commons-Attribution/No derivatives).
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Another journal refuses tobacco-sponsored research
Feb 28, 2010
The online, open-access journal PLoS Medicine said this week that it will no longer accept for publication reports of research sponsored by tobacco companies. The journal joins two of its sister publications, PLoS Biology ...
Tobacco companies' interests in smokeless tobacco products in Europe are driven by profit not health
Sep 10, 2013
Transnational tobacco companies' investments in smokeless tobacco products, such as snus (a moist tobacco product that is placed under the upper lip), in Europe are not due to a concern for the health impacts of smoking but ...
Greater transparency needed in publishing information from clinical trials
Jan 29, 2013
An initiative from the drugs regulator, the European Medicines Agency, to commit to releasing all of the information from clinical trials once the marketing authorization process has ended, which has been greeted with cautious ...
WHO chief accuses tobacco giant of 'sabotaging' EU health bill
Sep 11, 2013
The World Health Organisation chief on Wednesday accused tobacco giant Philip Morris of seeking to "sabotage" a proposed EU measure to clamp down on tobacco industry marketing aimed at women and youngsters.
Harmful effects of ultra-processed food and drink industries should be regulated
Feb 11, 2013
An international analysis of food, drink, and alcohol industry involvement in NCD policies shows that despite the common reliance on industry self-regulation and public-private partnerships to improve public health, there ...
Recommended for you
Healthy food rarely convenient for urban minorities
30 minutes ago
Despite the prevalence of corner and convenience stores in urban neighborhoods, many residents have to travel farther to find supermarkets that offer a wide variety of healthful food choices, finds a new ...
Telecare could help care home residents get a better night's sleep
46 minutes ago
A study of sleep habits in care homes has found that staffing levels, shift patterns and safety checks can significantly affect residents' ability to get a good night's sleep.
Study finds nearly a third of Pittsburgh homicides might have been prevented
50 minutes ago
(Medical Xpress)—More than 30 percent of the homicides in Pittsburgh last year were likely related to peer violence, not gang activity, and are the type of crime most readily prevented by early intervention, according to ...
Eye contact builds bedside trust: Doctors who make eye contact seem more empathetic to patients
1 hour ago
(Medical Xpress)—Doctors who make a lot of eye contact are viewed as more likable and empathetic by patients, according to a new Northwestern Medicine® study.
Food waste, diets in focus on UN World Food Day
2 hours ago
The United Nations marked World Food Day on Wednesday, warning against food waste as 842 million people go hungry and stressing the importance of healthy diets amid rising obesity.
Positive results of Phase 3 trial of 1-year contraceptive vaginal ring presented
8 hours ago
Today, the Population Council presented findings from a Phase 3 clinical trial that was designed to demonstrate the safety, efficacy, and acceptability of the Council's investigational one-year contraceptive vaginal ring ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
0 comments:
Post a Comment