by Christopher Vaughan
A small clinical trial of a device invented by researchers at the School of Medicine has shown that it can help reduce the size of existing scars when used after scar-revision surgery.
The same device was previously shown to minimize the development of scars after surgery, but this is the first time it has been tested as part of a procedure for reducing old scars.
"This is exciting because there are a lot of scars out there and a lot of people are bothered by them," said Michael Longaker, MD MBA, the Deane P. and Louise Mitchell Professor at the School of Medicine and a senior author of the study. The results of the study were published Jan. 28 in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery.
Longaker estimates that every year in the United States there are 80-100 million surgical incisions and 5-12 million accidental lacerations, all of which heal with a scar of some sort. "We don't know how many people are really bothered by scars, but we do know that every year 300,000 to 400,000 Americans approach their doctors to get their scars reduced," he said.
Scar formation has long been of interest to Longaker and the other senior author of the paper, Geoffrey Gurtner, MD, professor and associate chair of surgery. Previously, while at UC-San Francisco, Longaker studied how babies in the womb are able to heal without any scarring after fetal surgery. At Massachusetts General Hospital, Gurtner studied how mechanical pressure reduced scarring in burn healing.
Scar tissue is much tougher than normal skin, making it less susceptible to reinjury. But scars are also less flexible, they don't have the pores that are essential to regulating heat in our bodies, and many people feel their scars are unsightly. Extensive scarring can be much more than a cosmetic problem; scarring can make certain movements and activities difficult or painful.
Longaker and Gurtner's device is what they call a "stress shield." As cuts and injuries heal, normal tension in the skin pulls the edges of the wound away from each other, which widens the scar as it forms. The device precisely pulls together the skin around the wound to reduce that tension at the injury site.
"Doctors try to take off these mechanical forces using steri-strips or other bandaging, but most don't do this with any degree of precision," Gurtner said. "They either pull too much, which creates blistering in the skin, or don't pull enough, and the scar then tends to grow during healing."
The device, which is manufactured by the Menlo Park, Calif., company Neodyne Biosciences Inc., has received clearance for marketing by the Food and Drug Administration, according to Bill Beasly, Neodyne's president. Longaker and Gurtner have a financial stake in the company but did not perform any of the surgeries in the clinical trial, which was funded by Neodyne. The surgeries were done by an independent surgical center in Palo Alto, Calif.
Currently, scar revision surgery does not work very well. Scars are cut out, the edges of the incision are closed, and surgeons work to make the new scar less obtrusive than the old one. But the revision surgery using current methods doesn't work very well, Longaker said. "Most of the time, after a year the patient feels that the scar is just as bad as it ever was," he says.
In this clinical trial, surgeons cut out old scars on each of 10 patients and then placed the scar-reduction device over half of the incision; the other half they closed using traditional methods. After the study, patients were offered the chance to have the traditionally revised section of the scar closed using either of the two methods so that the two sides matched.
Six months after surgery, photos of the two halves of the scar were compared by four independent surgeons who did not know which sides of the scars had been treated with the device. Using a visual scoring system, the judges determined that the scar on the side treated with the scar-reduction device was significantly smaller. "It was pretty obvious," Longaker said. "It was not even subtle."
"This is the first demonstration of a new therapy that affects this very ubiquitous problem, and the beginning of a new class of therapy that works against fibrotic disease," Longaker says.
Explore further: Fat grafting helps patients with scarring problems, reports
More information: "The Embrace Device Significantly Decreases Scarring Following Scar Revision Surgery in a Randomized Controlled Trial." Lim, Angeline F.; Weintraub, Jennifer; Kaplan, Ernest N.; Januszyk, Michael; Cowley, Christy; McLaughlin, Peggy; Beasley, Bill; Gurtner, Geoffrey C.; Longaker, Michael T. Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery. 133(2):398-405, February 2014. DOI: 10.1097/01.prs.0000436526.64046.d0
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
New device could reduce surgical scarring
May 23, 2011
Researchers at Stanford University have developed a special wound dressing that they report was able to significantly reduce scar tissue caused by incisions.
Scientists discover possible treatment to reduce scarring
Jul 06, 2012
Whether from surgery or battle wounds, ugly scars can affect body and mind. Now a new research report appearing online in the FASEB Journal offers a new strategy to reduce or eliminate scars on the skin. Specifically, scient ...
Fat grafting helps patients with scarring problems, reports
Sep 25, 2013
Millions of people with scars suffer from pain, discomfort, and inability to perform regular activities. Some may have to revert to addicting pain medicine to get rid of their ailments. Now, and with a new methodology, such ...
Lasers deemed highly effective treatment for excessive scars
Nov 27, 2013
Current laser therapy approaches are effective for treating excessive scars resulting from abnormal wound healing, concludes a special topic paper in the December issue of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, the official medica ...
Treatment interval doesn't affect benefit of acne laser Tx
Oct 19, 2013
(HealthDay)—Fractional CO2 laser treatment is safe and seems effective for atrophic acne scars, with no difference observed for treatment with a one- or three-month interval, according to a study published ...
Recommended for you
Diaphragm pacing in spinal cord injury successful in weaning patients from ventilators
Feb 07, 2014
A new study published in the Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery finds that diaphragm pacing (DP) stimulation in spinal cord-injured patients is successful not only in weaning patients from mechanical ventilators but al ...
Ear gauge piercing repair surgery quick, nearly painless
Feb 06, 2014
At age 15, Cody Selga joined the wave of teenagers inserting gauges or plugs into their ears to stretch their earlobes.
One in three patients bitten by cats in hand hospitalized, infections common
Feb 06, 2014
Dogs aren't the only pets who sometimes bite the hands that feed them. Cats do too, and when they strike a hand, can inject bacteria deep into joints and tissue, perfect breeding grounds for infection. Cat bites to the hand ...
New weight-loss surgery may not ease chronic heartburn
Feb 05, 2014
(HealthDay)—Obese people who are considering weight-loss surgery should choose their procedure carefully if they hope to be free of chronic heartburn, a new study suggests.
Some receive unnecessary prioritization for liver transplantation, study says
Feb 05, 2014
Patients waiting for liver transplants who develop hepatopulmonary syndrome (HPS), a lung disorder associated with end-stage liver disease, are eligible to move up on the wait list. In a new paper published in Gastroenterology, howeve ...
Innovative technique creates large skin flaps for full-face resurfacing
Feb 05, 2014
Patients with massive burns causing complete loss of the facial skin pose a difficult challenge for reconstructive surgeons. Now a group of surgeons in China have developed an innovative technique for creating a one-piece ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2014, Science X network
by Christopher Vaughan
A small clinical trial of a device invented by researchers at the School of Medicine has shown that it can help reduce the size of existing scars when used after scar-revision surgery.
The same device was previously shown to minimize the development of scars after surgery, but this is the first time it has been tested as part of a procedure for reducing old scars.
"This is exciting because there are a lot of scars out there and a lot of people are bothered by them," said Michael Longaker, MD MBA, the Deane P. and Louise Mitchell Professor at the School of Medicine and a senior author of the study. The results of the study were published Jan. 28 in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery.
Longaker estimates that every year in the United States there are 80-100 million surgical incisions and 5-12 million accidental lacerations, all of which heal with a scar of some sort. "We don't know how many people are really bothered by scars, but we do know that every year 300,000 to 400,000 Americans approach their doctors to get their scars reduced," he said.
Scar formation has long been of interest to Longaker and the other senior author of the paper, Geoffrey Gurtner, MD, professor and associate chair of surgery. Previously, while at UC-San Francisco, Longaker studied how babies in the womb are able to heal without any scarring after fetal surgery. At Massachusetts General Hospital, Gurtner studied how mechanical pressure reduced scarring in burn healing.
Scar tissue is much tougher than normal skin, making it less susceptible to reinjury. But scars are also less flexible, they don't have the pores that are essential to regulating heat in our bodies, and many people feel their scars are unsightly. Extensive scarring can be much more than a cosmetic problem; scarring can make certain movements and activities difficult or painful.
Longaker and Gurtner's device is what they call a "stress shield." As cuts and injuries heal, normal tension in the skin pulls the edges of the wound away from each other, which widens the scar as it forms. The device precisely pulls together the skin around the wound to reduce that tension at the injury site.
"Doctors try to take off these mechanical forces using steri-strips or other bandaging, but most don't do this with any degree of precision," Gurtner said. "They either pull too much, which creates blistering in the skin, or don't pull enough, and the scar then tends to grow during healing."
The device, which is manufactured by the Menlo Park, Calif., company Neodyne Biosciences Inc., has received clearance for marketing by the Food and Drug Administration, according to Bill Beasly, Neodyne's president. Longaker and Gurtner have a financial stake in the company but did not perform any of the surgeries in the clinical trial, which was funded by Neodyne. The surgeries were done by an independent surgical center in Palo Alto, Calif.
Currently, scar revision surgery does not work very well. Scars are cut out, the edges of the incision are closed, and surgeons work to make the new scar less obtrusive than the old one. But the revision surgery using current methods doesn't work very well, Longaker said. "Most of the time, after a year the patient feels that the scar is just as bad as it ever was," he says.
In this clinical trial, surgeons cut out old scars on each of 10 patients and then placed the scar-reduction device over half of the incision; the other half they closed using traditional methods. After the study, patients were offered the chance to have the traditionally revised section of the scar closed using either of the two methods so that the two sides matched.
Six months after surgery, photos of the two halves of the scar were compared by four independent surgeons who did not know which sides of the scars had been treated with the device. Using a visual scoring system, the judges determined that the scar on the side treated with the scar-reduction device was significantly smaller. "It was pretty obvious," Longaker said. "It was not even subtle."
"This is the first demonstration of a new therapy that affects this very ubiquitous problem, and the beginning of a new class of therapy that works against fibrotic disease," Longaker says.
Explore further: Fat grafting helps patients with scarring problems, reports
More information: "The Embrace Device Significantly Decreases Scarring Following Scar Revision Surgery in a Randomized Controlled Trial." Lim, Angeline F.; Weintraub, Jennifer; Kaplan, Ernest N.; Januszyk, Michael; Cowley, Christy; McLaughlin, Peggy; Beasley, Bill; Gurtner, Geoffrey C.; Longaker, Michael T. Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery. 133(2):398-405, February 2014. DOI: 10.1097/01.prs.0000436526.64046.d0
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
New device could reduce surgical scarring
May 23, 2011
Researchers at Stanford University have developed a special wound dressing that they report was able to significantly reduce scar tissue caused by incisions.
Scientists discover possible treatment to reduce scarring
Jul 06, 2012
Whether from surgery or battle wounds, ugly scars can affect body and mind. Now a new research report appearing online in the FASEB Journal offers a new strategy to reduce or eliminate scars on the skin. Specifically, scient ...
Fat grafting helps patients with scarring problems, reports
Sep 25, 2013
Millions of people with scars suffer from pain, discomfort, and inability to perform regular activities. Some may have to revert to addicting pain medicine to get rid of their ailments. Now, and with a new methodology, such ...
Lasers deemed highly effective treatment for excessive scars
Nov 27, 2013
Current laser therapy approaches are effective for treating excessive scars resulting from abnormal wound healing, concludes a special topic paper in the December issue of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, the official medica ...
Treatment interval doesn't affect benefit of acne laser Tx
Oct 19, 2013
(HealthDay)—Fractional CO2 laser treatment is safe and seems effective for atrophic acne scars, with no difference observed for treatment with a one- or three-month interval, according to a study published ...
Recommended for you
Diaphragm pacing in spinal cord injury successful in weaning patients from ventilators
Feb 07, 2014
A new study published in the Journal of Trauma and Acute Care Surgery finds that diaphragm pacing (DP) stimulation in spinal cord-injured patients is successful not only in weaning patients from mechanical ventilators but al ...
Ear gauge piercing repair surgery quick, nearly painless
Feb 06, 2014
At age 15, Cody Selga joined the wave of teenagers inserting gauges or plugs into their ears to stretch their earlobes.
One in three patients bitten by cats in hand hospitalized, infections common
Feb 06, 2014
Dogs aren't the only pets who sometimes bite the hands that feed them. Cats do too, and when they strike a hand, can inject bacteria deep into joints and tissue, perfect breeding grounds for infection. Cat bites to the hand ...
New weight-loss surgery may not ease chronic heartburn
Feb 05, 2014
(HealthDay)—Obese people who are considering weight-loss surgery should choose their procedure carefully if they hope to be free of chronic heartburn, a new study suggests.
Some receive unnecessary prioritization for liver transplantation, study says
Feb 05, 2014
Patients waiting for liver transplants who develop hepatopulmonary syndrome (HPS), a lung disorder associated with end-stage liver disease, are eligible to move up on the wait list. In a new paper published in Gastroenterology, howeve ...
Innovative technique creates large skin flaps for full-face resurfacing
Feb 05, 2014
Patients with massive burns causing complete loss of the facial skin pose a difficult challenge for reconstructive surgeons. Now a group of surgeons in China have developed an innovative technique for creating a one-piece ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2014, Science X network
0 comments:
Post a Comment