Women who use surrogate mothers to have a child do not have a legal right to maternity leave when the baby is born, the European Court of Justice ruled on Tuesday.
The European Union's highest court said EU "law does not establish a right to paid leave equal to maternity leave or adoption leave" for women having a child by a surrogate.
At the same time, EU member states are free to apply more accommodating rules if they choose to do so, it added.
The court was considering two cases: one of a British woman who could not get pregnant and had a child, fathered by her husband but carried by another woman and using another woman's egg.
The husband and wife were subsequently given full parental rights over the child with the consent of the surrogate mother.
In the second case, a woman in Ireland who was fertile but had no uterus, used a surrogate mother in California. She and her husband were the child's full biological parents and recognised as such under US law.
In both cases, however, when the women asked for maternity leave so as to look after their babies, their employers turned them down on the grounds that neither had gone through a pregnancy or adopted their children.
Reviewing the cases against EU legislation on conditions for working mothers, fair treatment and physical handicap, the court said it could find no grounds to say that such a refusal of maternity leave breached EU law.
The relevant 1992 law stated that maternity leave must be granted to a woman "who has been pregnant and who has given birth to a child," it noted.
Explore further: US court rules lesbian egg donor has parent rights
© 2014 AFP
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
US court rules lesbian egg donor has parent rights
Nov 07, 2013
The Florida Supreme Court has ruled that a woman who donated an egg to her lesbian partner has parental rights to the child, and on Thursday it ordered a lower court to determine custody and visitation rights.
Longer maternity leaves lower women's risk of postpartum depression
Dec 12, 2013
The more leave time from work that a woman takes after giving birth—up to six months—the better protected she will be from experiencing post-partum depression, according to a study led by Dr. Rada K. ...
Genetic mother wins surrogacy lawsuit in Ireland
Mar 05, 2013
The genetic mother of twins born through a surrogate pregnancy has defeated the Irish government in a landmark lawsuit and won the right to be declared the mother on the children's birth certificates.
Low-birth Greece takes a further hit from crisis
Apr 21, 2013
In a nursery of a private maternity hospital in Athens, three mothers feed their newborns while another three babies nap nearby. The room has only a few cots, and yet a number lie empty.
Does mum have the final say? New study reveals confusion in maternity care
May 02, 2013
(Medical Xpress)—A study from The University of Queensland has highlighted the tension doctors and midwives experience when supporting women's right to decide what happens to them and their babies.
Recommended for you
Canadian drinking-age laws have significant effect on deaths among young males
8 minutes ago
A recent study by a University of Northern British Columbia-based scientist associated with the UBC Faculty of Medicine and UNBC's Northern Medical Program demonstrates that Canada's drinking-age laws have ...
Many low-income women don't want to leave hospital after false-labor diagnosis
10 minutes ago
More than 40 percent of pregnant low-income women discharged from the hospital after a diagnosis of false or early labor did not want to be sent home, with the most common reasons being that they were in too much pain or ...
Study uses video-game device with goal of preventing patient falls
1 hour ago
Technology used in video games is making its way to hospital rooms, where researchers at the University of Missouri hope to learn new ways to prevent falls among hospital patients.
Will health care reform require new population health management strategies?
1 hour ago
In response to the 2010 Affordable Care Act, employers may no long offer traditional employee health care benefits as they protect themselves from rising health care costs and seek to minimize their risk. ...
Positive memories of exercise spur future workouts
4 hours ago
Getting motivated to exercise can be a challenge, but new research from the University of New Hampshire shows that simply remembering a positive memory about exercise may be just what it takes to get on the treadmill. This ...
Parents matter more than they think in how their children eat
5 hours ago
(Medical Xpress)—Helping children learn to eat well can be a challenge. Some children happily eat whatever is put in front of them while others seem to eat like birds and exist more on air than food. ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2014, Science X network
Women who use surrogate mothers to have a child do not have a legal right to maternity leave when the baby is born, the European Court of Justice ruled on Tuesday.
The European Union's highest court said EU "law does not establish a right to paid leave equal to maternity leave or adoption leave" for women having a child by a surrogate.
At the same time, EU member states are free to apply more accommodating rules if they choose to do so, it added.
The court was considering two cases: one of a British woman who could not get pregnant and had a child, fathered by her husband but carried by another woman and using another woman's egg.
The husband and wife were subsequently given full parental rights over the child with the consent of the surrogate mother.
In the second case, a woman in Ireland who was fertile but had no uterus, used a surrogate mother in California. She and her husband were the child's full biological parents and recognised as such under US law.
In both cases, however, when the women asked for maternity leave so as to look after their babies, their employers turned them down on the grounds that neither had gone through a pregnancy or adopted their children.
Reviewing the cases against EU legislation on conditions for working mothers, fair treatment and physical handicap, the court said it could find no grounds to say that such a refusal of maternity leave breached EU law.
The relevant 1992 law stated that maternity leave must be granted to a woman "who has been pregnant and who has given birth to a child," it noted.
Explore further: US court rules lesbian egg donor has parent rights
© 2014 AFP
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
US court rules lesbian egg donor has parent rights
Nov 07, 2013
The Florida Supreme Court has ruled that a woman who donated an egg to her lesbian partner has parental rights to the child, and on Thursday it ordered a lower court to determine custody and visitation rights.
Longer maternity leaves lower women's risk of postpartum depression
Dec 12, 2013
The more leave time from work that a woman takes after giving birth—up to six months—the better protected she will be from experiencing post-partum depression, according to a study led by Dr. Rada K. ...
Genetic mother wins surrogacy lawsuit in Ireland
Mar 05, 2013
The genetic mother of twins born through a surrogate pregnancy has defeated the Irish government in a landmark lawsuit and won the right to be declared the mother on the children's birth certificates.
Low-birth Greece takes a further hit from crisis
Apr 21, 2013
In a nursery of a private maternity hospital in Athens, three mothers feed their newborns while another three babies nap nearby. The room has only a few cots, and yet a number lie empty.
Does mum have the final say? New study reveals confusion in maternity care
May 02, 2013
(Medical Xpress)—A study from The University of Queensland has highlighted the tension doctors and midwives experience when supporting women's right to decide what happens to them and their babies.
Recommended for you
Canadian drinking-age laws have significant effect on deaths among young males
8 minutes ago
A recent study by a University of Northern British Columbia-based scientist associated with the UBC Faculty of Medicine and UNBC's Northern Medical Program demonstrates that Canada's drinking-age laws have ...
Many low-income women don't want to leave hospital after false-labor diagnosis
10 minutes ago
More than 40 percent of pregnant low-income women discharged from the hospital after a diagnosis of false or early labor did not want to be sent home, with the most common reasons being that they were in too much pain or ...
Study uses video-game device with goal of preventing patient falls
1 hour ago
Technology used in video games is making its way to hospital rooms, where researchers at the University of Missouri hope to learn new ways to prevent falls among hospital patients.
Will health care reform require new population health management strategies?
1 hour ago
In response to the 2010 Affordable Care Act, employers may no long offer traditional employee health care benefits as they protect themselves from rising health care costs and seek to minimize their risk. ...
Positive memories of exercise spur future workouts
4 hours ago
Getting motivated to exercise can be a challenge, but new research from the University of New Hampshire shows that simply remembering a positive memory about exercise may be just what it takes to get on the treadmill. This ...
Parents matter more than they think in how their children eat
5 hours ago
(Medical Xpress)—Helping children learn to eat well can be a challenge. Some children happily eat whatever is put in front of them while others seem to eat like birds and exist more on air than food. ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2014, Science X network
0 comments:
Post a Comment