by Cher Thornhill
Credit: Tim Dobson
(Medical Xpress)—A brain area activated by group decisions can distinguish people more likely to conform to the will of a group, say researchers from UCL.
The team, led by Dr Tali Sharot, UCL Affective Brain Lab, monitored the brain activity of individuals in groups of five people choosing food or drink they'd like to consume before and after being told the most popular choice in their group.
The results showed that people were likely to conform to the most popular choice in their group if their original preference was different.
Caroline Charpentier (UCL Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience) said: "Most people don't think their everyday decisions, such as having eggs on toast for breakfast or a pint of lager at the pub, are influenced by other people's preferences."
She added: "But our results suggest that when other people make different choices than you, for example your friends order beer while you order wine, your brain records this information and this signal is mirrored in your brain later on, for example when you order another drink, making you more likely to choose beer, even if you initially preferred wine".
The team, led by Dr Tali Sharot, used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to monitor the brain responses of 20 volunteers during a decision-making task, while 78 more volunteers completed the task simultaneously on computers located outside the MRI room. They came to the lab in small groups of five.
In one session, volunteers were shown 60 pairs of food and drink items and asked to select which item of each pair they would prefer to consume at the end of the experiment. Straight after making this choice, the participants were told which item most people in their group selected. This part of the experiment provided the volunteers with social feedback.
Volunteers then took part in a following session a few minutes later, when they opted again for which item they would prefer to consume from the same series of pairs, but this time made the choice for themselves and did not receive any social feedback.
After the experiment, the participants completed a personality questionnaire that assessed trait conformity, which measures their general tendency to follow other people's ideas and behaviours. Comparison of results from the choice experiment and conformity questionnaire indeed showed that people who scored high on trait conformity were about twice as likely to change their food choices to agree with the group decision as people who scored low for conformity.
What differed between the brains of people who were more likely to conform and people who held on to their own opinion?
The imaging study showed that the orbito-frontal cortex (OFC) – a region at the front of the brain that has been associated with emotional and social behaviour – was active during the two choice sessions and distinguished between these two groups of people.
Miss Charpentier said: "The orbito-frontal cortex was the only region specifically activated, and the first area to react to group disagreement. This region was activated both at the time of the initial social conflict (when your friends all choose beer while you prefer wine) and also later when you make an individual choice (when you order another drink for yourself)."
The OFC has previously been associated with emotions and social behaviour. Some clinical studies have suggested that people with brain damage in the OFC may behave inappropriately in groups.
Miss Charpentier concluded: "When OFC activity during the initial social conflict is mirrored in your brain at a later time when you make an individual choice, you are more likely to change your choice and follow the group. This is what happens in 'high conformers'. In other words, it is the temporal dynamics of the OFC that distinguishes "conformers" from people who hold on to their own initial opinion".
Explore further: Drinking buddies deny copying alcoholic drink orders
More information: The paper, titled "The Brain's Temporal Dynamics from a Collective Decision to Individual Action" is available online: http://ift.tt/1hO9lQV
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Drinking buddies deny copying alcoholic drink orders
Mar 04, 2014
People who copy their friend's drinking behaviour will deny that their decision has been influenced, researchers at the University of Liverpool have shown.
Brain study shows why some people are more in tune with what they want
Dec 09, 2012
Wellcome Trust researchers have discovered how the brain assesses confidence in its decisions. The findings explain why some people have better insight into their choices than others.
Social media, social pressures and the power of opinion
Sep 21, 2011
(PhysOrg.com) -- New research from HP's Social Computing Research Group suggests that while social media and the recommendations of others can cause you to change your mind regarding a product or service, it i ...
Neuroscientists discover way to increase product value without making changes to it
Mar 10, 2014
(Medical Xpress)—A team of researchers working at the University of Texas has discovered a way to cause the perceived value of a product to rise, without changing the product itself: add a button that makes ...
Scientists identify link between size of brain region and conformity
Feb 20, 2012
Every generation has its James Dean: the rebel who refuses to follow the path beaten by their peers. Now, a new study in Current Biology has found a link between the amount of grey matter in one specific brain region and an ...
Recommended for you
AAN issues findings on use of medical marijuana in treatment of certain brain diseases
14 hours ago
A review by the American Academy of Neurology of available scientific research on the use of medical marijuana in brain diseases finds certain forms of medical marijuana can help treat some symptoms of multiple sclerosis ...
Scientists hunt down origin of Huntington's disease in the brain
19 hours ago
The gene mutation that causes Huntington's disease appears in every cell in the body, yet kills only two types of brain cells. Why? UCLA scientists used a unique approach to switch the gene off in individual ...
Research shows strategic thinking strengthens intellectual capacity
22 hours ago
Strategy-based cognitive training has the potential to enhance cognitive performance and spill over to real-life benefit according to a data-driven perspective article by the Center for BrainHealth at The ...
Laughter may work like meditation in the brain
Apr 27, 2014
(HealthDay)—Laughter triggers brain waves similar to those associated with meditation, according to a small new study.
Interplay of rhythms makes brain centers communicate
Apr 25, 2014
Tübingen neuroscientists say differing rhythms coordinate the neural activity governing movement.
Seeking the causes of hyperactivity
Apr 25, 2014
The 60 trillion cells that comprise our bodies communicate constantly. Information travels when chemical compounds released by some cells are received by receptors in the membrane of another cell. In a paper ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2014, Science X network
by Cher Thornhill
Credit: Tim Dobson
(Medical Xpress)—A brain area activated by group decisions can distinguish people more likely to conform to the will of a group, say researchers from UCL.
The team, led by Dr Tali Sharot, UCL Affective Brain Lab, monitored the brain activity of individuals in groups of five people choosing food or drink they'd like to consume before and after being told the most popular choice in their group.
The results showed that people were likely to conform to the most popular choice in their group if their original preference was different.
Caroline Charpentier (UCL Institute of Cognitive Neuroscience) said: "Most people don't think their everyday decisions, such as having eggs on toast for breakfast or a pint of lager at the pub, are influenced by other people's preferences."
She added: "But our results suggest that when other people make different choices than you, for example your friends order beer while you order wine, your brain records this information and this signal is mirrored in your brain later on, for example when you order another drink, making you more likely to choose beer, even if you initially preferred wine".
The team, led by Dr Tali Sharot, used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to monitor the brain responses of 20 volunteers during a decision-making task, while 78 more volunteers completed the task simultaneously on computers located outside the MRI room. They came to the lab in small groups of five.
In one session, volunteers were shown 60 pairs of food and drink items and asked to select which item of each pair they would prefer to consume at the end of the experiment. Straight after making this choice, the participants were told which item most people in their group selected. This part of the experiment provided the volunteers with social feedback.
Volunteers then took part in a following session a few minutes later, when they opted again for which item they would prefer to consume from the same series of pairs, but this time made the choice for themselves and did not receive any social feedback.
After the experiment, the participants completed a personality questionnaire that assessed trait conformity, which measures their general tendency to follow other people's ideas and behaviours. Comparison of results from the choice experiment and conformity questionnaire indeed showed that people who scored high on trait conformity were about twice as likely to change their food choices to agree with the group decision as people who scored low for conformity.
What differed between the brains of people who were more likely to conform and people who held on to their own opinion?
The imaging study showed that the orbito-frontal cortex (OFC) – a region at the front of the brain that has been associated with emotional and social behaviour – was active during the two choice sessions and distinguished between these two groups of people.
Miss Charpentier said: "The orbito-frontal cortex was the only region specifically activated, and the first area to react to group disagreement. This region was activated both at the time of the initial social conflict (when your friends all choose beer while you prefer wine) and also later when you make an individual choice (when you order another drink for yourself)."
The OFC has previously been associated with emotions and social behaviour. Some clinical studies have suggested that people with brain damage in the OFC may behave inappropriately in groups.
Miss Charpentier concluded: "When OFC activity during the initial social conflict is mirrored in your brain at a later time when you make an individual choice, you are more likely to change your choice and follow the group. This is what happens in 'high conformers'. In other words, it is the temporal dynamics of the OFC that distinguishes "conformers" from people who hold on to their own initial opinion".
Explore further: Drinking buddies deny copying alcoholic drink orders
More information: The paper, titled "The Brain's Temporal Dynamics from a Collective Decision to Individual Action" is available online: http://ift.tt/1hO9lQV
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Drinking buddies deny copying alcoholic drink orders
Mar 04, 2014
People who copy their friend's drinking behaviour will deny that their decision has been influenced, researchers at the University of Liverpool have shown.
Brain study shows why some people are more in tune with what they want
Dec 09, 2012
Wellcome Trust researchers have discovered how the brain assesses confidence in its decisions. The findings explain why some people have better insight into their choices than others.
Social media, social pressures and the power of opinion
Sep 21, 2011
(PhysOrg.com) -- New research from HP's Social Computing Research Group suggests that while social media and the recommendations of others can cause you to change your mind regarding a product or service, it i ...
Neuroscientists discover way to increase product value without making changes to it
Mar 10, 2014
(Medical Xpress)—A team of researchers working at the University of Texas has discovered a way to cause the perceived value of a product to rise, without changing the product itself: add a button that makes ...
Scientists identify link between size of brain region and conformity
Feb 20, 2012
Every generation has its James Dean: the rebel who refuses to follow the path beaten by their peers. Now, a new study in Current Biology has found a link between the amount of grey matter in one specific brain region and an ...
Recommended for you
AAN issues findings on use of medical marijuana in treatment of certain brain diseases
14 hours ago
A review by the American Academy of Neurology of available scientific research on the use of medical marijuana in brain diseases finds certain forms of medical marijuana can help treat some symptoms of multiple sclerosis ...
Scientists hunt down origin of Huntington's disease in the brain
19 hours ago
The gene mutation that causes Huntington's disease appears in every cell in the body, yet kills only two types of brain cells. Why? UCLA scientists used a unique approach to switch the gene off in individual ...
Research shows strategic thinking strengthens intellectual capacity
22 hours ago
Strategy-based cognitive training has the potential to enhance cognitive performance and spill over to real-life benefit according to a data-driven perspective article by the Center for BrainHealth at The ...
Laughter may work like meditation in the brain
Apr 27, 2014
(HealthDay)—Laughter triggers brain waves similar to those associated with meditation, according to a small new study.
Interplay of rhythms makes brain centers communicate
Apr 25, 2014
Tübingen neuroscientists say differing rhythms coordinate the neural activity governing movement.
Seeking the causes of hyperactivity
Apr 25, 2014
The 60 trillion cells that comprise our bodies communicate constantly. Information travels when chemical compounds released by some cells are received by receptors in the membrane of another cell. In a paper ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2014, Science X network
0 comments:
Post a Comment