by Kathryn M. O'neill
Amy Finkelstein, an MIT economist, is principal investigator of the groundbreaking Oregon Health Insurance Experiment. Credit: Len Rubenstein
When Oregon voted in 2008 to use a lottery to determine which low-income adults to add to its Medicaid rolls, Stephen Colbert mocked the effort as "gambling for health insurance."
MIT economist Amy Finkelstein wasn't laughing.
"I heard about it and immediately thought, 'Oh my god, drop everything and get on this!'" says Finkelstein, the Ford Professor of Economics at MIT and a principal investigator of the groundbreaking Oregon Health Insurance Experiment. "What they saw as humorous, we saw as an unprecedented opportunity to bring the gold standard in scientific research to one of the most pressing questions of our day."
By using a lottery to assign coverage, Oregon had unintentionally created the perfect conditions for a randomized controlled trial that could reveal the true costs and benefits of health insurance. Since the population that received coverage was statistically equivalent to the group that didn't, economists could simply compare outcomes between groups to gauge the effects of insurance. "Remarkably, this had never been done before in the United States," says Finkelstein, who won the 2012 John Bates Clark Medal from the American Economic Association for most significant contribution to economic thought by an economist under 40.
The results were stunning. Researchers found, for example, that Medicaid increased health care use and reduced rates of depression, despite often-heard claims that Medicaid coverage was worthless. Medicaid also increased visits to the emergency room—notwithstanding many policymakers' predictions to the contrary. "The beauty and power of randomized evaluations is that they really allow you to be surprised," Finkelstein says.
The study also showed that health insurance successfully provides a financial safety net. "People often think of health insurance as a way of improving health, but to economists, health insurance is a financial instrument. The first idea is not to improve health but to protect you financially against large medical expenses," Finkelstein says. "We found Medicaid basically eliminates the prospect that a person will have a catastrophic financial issue."
The results from the Oregon Health Insurance Experiment made headlines again and again, underscoring for Finkelstein the power that randomized evaluations have to change both public perception and policy debate. "Nobody is arguing about what the results are," Finkelstein says. Instead, they're arguing about what to do with this new information—and that is the way of the future.
To catalyze a wave of similar research across the continent, Finkelstein last year helped launch the North American branch of MIT's Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab (J-PAL), which pioneered the use of randomized evaluation to evaluate social programs.
"One of the reasons I cofounded J-PAL North America with Professor Lawrence Katz of Harvard is because we think [randomized evaluation] should be much closer to the norm than the exception in health policy," Finkelstein says.
Since most health care programs start small and ramp up, they are ripe for regular testing, Finkelstein notes. Already, J-PAL North America affiliates have completed five health-care studies, and the lab has lined up more than two dozen academics to conduct randomized evaluations of a wide range of social issues, from health care to education, crime, and discrimination.
As for Finkelstein herself, she is currently studying a Camden, New Jersey, program that provides intense after-care interventions for patients at high risk for repeat hospitalizations. Since the program can't yet accommodate all such patients, Finkelstein and her partners will compare results between those who receive the intervention and those who don't to see whether the program meets its goal of preventing future hospital visits.
"Ideally, most policies going forward would have an evaluation component built in so that we can tell the effects of a program," Finkelstein says. "My real hope is that this will become a movement."
Explore further: MIT economist explains why randomized trials can improve medical care
This story is republished courtesy of MIT News (http://ift.tt/ABbm9r), a popular site that covers news about MIT research, innovation and teaching.
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
MIT economist explains why randomized trials can improve medical care
Feb 13, 2015
About 80 percent of studies of U.S. medical interventions use randomized controlled trials (RCTs), the gold standard of laboratory research. But only about 18 percent of studies of U.S. health care delivery ...
Having Medicaid increases emergency room visits
Jan 02, 2014
Adults who are covered by Medicaid use emergency rooms 40 percent more than those in similar circumstances who do not have health insurance, according to a unique new study, co-authored by an MIT economist, that sheds empirical ...
Expanding Medicaid: Mental and financial health improve, but no improvement shown in physical health
May 01, 2013
New findings from the Oregon Health Insurance Experiment show that Medicaid coverage had no detectable effect on the prevalence of diabetes, high cholesterol, or high blood pressure, but substantially reduced depression, ...
Study finds health insurance helps lower-income Americans avoid depression, diabetes, major financial shocks
May 03, 2013
Enrollment in Medicaid helps lower-income Americans overcome depression, get proper treatment for diabetes, and avoid catastrophic medical bills, but does not appear to reduce the prevalence of diabetes, high blood pressure ...
New insight: Consumers avoid high-deductible plans if they expect to reduce their use of medical care
Feb 27, 2013
Economists often talk about "moral hazard," the idea that people's behavior changes in the presence of insurance. In finance, for instance, investors may take more risks if they know they will be bailed out, ...
Recommended for you
Insuring undocumented residents could help solve multiple US health care challenges
40 minutes ago
Latinos are the largest ethnic minority group in the United States, and it's expected that by 2050 they will comprise almost 30 percent of the U.S. population. Yet they are also the most underserved by health care and health ...
Researchers find towels to be a top source of cross contamination within the kitchen
1 hour ago
Although only 9 percent of reported foodborne illness outbreaks occur in the home, scientists estimate the actual number of incidents is much higher. Research shows a leading cause of cross contamination ...
Excessive vitamin intake in pregnant rats impacts food choices in offspring
1 hour ago
A research group at the Department of Nutritional Sciences at the University of Toronto, Faculty of Medicine has been using a rat model to see how maternal intake of above-requirement vitamins (A, D, E, and K) impact offspring's ...
Poll: Many see negative impact if court nixes health law aid
3 hours ago
With a decision due by summer in a Supreme Court case that could unravel President Barack Obama's health care law, a new poll finds many Americans have heard nothing about the case. But when the potential ...
New tobacco atlas details scale, harms of tobacco epidemic
4 hours ago
The Tobacco Atlas, Fifth Edition ("The Atlas"), and its companion mobile app and website TobaccoAtlas.org, were unveiled today by the American Cancer Society and World Lung Foundation at the 16th World Conference on Tobacco o ...
Melatonin can help you get a good night's sleep in a noisy environment
10 hours ago
Using melatonin could provide more and better quality sleep compared to using an eye mask and earplugs in a simulated noisy and illuminated environment, according to research published in open access journal Critical Care. This s ...
User comments
Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more
Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.
© Medical Xpress 2011-2014, Science X network
by Kathryn M. O'neill
Amy Finkelstein, an MIT economist, is principal investigator of the groundbreaking Oregon Health Insurance Experiment. Credit: Len Rubenstein
When Oregon voted in 2008 to use a lottery to determine which low-income adults to add to its Medicaid rolls, Stephen Colbert mocked the effort as "gambling for health insurance."
MIT economist Amy Finkelstein wasn't laughing.
"I heard about it and immediately thought, 'Oh my god, drop everything and get on this!'" says Finkelstein, the Ford Professor of Economics at MIT and a principal investigator of the groundbreaking Oregon Health Insurance Experiment. "What they saw as humorous, we saw as an unprecedented opportunity to bring the gold standard in scientific research to one of the most pressing questions of our day."
By using a lottery to assign coverage, Oregon had unintentionally created the perfect conditions for a randomized controlled trial that could reveal the true costs and benefits of health insurance. Since the population that received coverage was statistically equivalent to the group that didn't, economists could simply compare outcomes between groups to gauge the effects of insurance. "Remarkably, this had never been done before in the United States," says Finkelstein, who won the 2012 John Bates Clark Medal from the American Economic Association for most significant contribution to economic thought by an economist under 40.
The results were stunning. Researchers found, for example, that Medicaid increased health care use and reduced rates of depression, despite often-heard claims that Medicaid coverage was worthless. Medicaid also increased visits to the emergency room—notwithstanding many policymakers' predictions to the contrary. "The beauty and power of randomized evaluations is that they really allow you to be surprised," Finkelstein says.
The study also showed that health insurance successfully provides a financial safety net. "People often think of health insurance as a way of improving health, but to economists, health insurance is a financial instrument. The first idea is not to improve health but to protect you financially against large medical expenses," Finkelstein says. "We found Medicaid basically eliminates the prospect that a person will have a catastrophic financial issue."
The results from the Oregon Health Insurance Experiment made headlines again and again, underscoring for Finkelstein the power that randomized evaluations have to change both public perception and policy debate. "Nobody is arguing about what the results are," Finkelstein says. Instead, they're arguing about what to do with this new information—and that is the way of the future.
To catalyze a wave of similar research across the continent, Finkelstein last year helped launch the North American branch of MIT's Abdul Latif Jameel Poverty Action Lab (J-PAL), which pioneered the use of randomized evaluation to evaluate social programs.
"One of the reasons I cofounded J-PAL North America with Professor Lawrence Katz of Harvard is because we think [randomized evaluation] should be much closer to the norm than the exception in health policy," Finkelstein says.
Since most health care programs start small and ramp up, they are ripe for regular testing, Finkelstein notes. Already, J-PAL North America affiliates have completed five health-care studies, and the lab has lined up more than two dozen academics to conduct randomized evaluations of a wide range of social issues, from health care to education, crime, and discrimination.
As for Finkelstein herself, she is currently studying a Camden, New Jersey, program that provides intense after-care interventions for patients at high risk for repeat hospitalizations. Since the program can't yet accommodate all such patients, Finkelstein and her partners will compare results between those who receive the intervention and those who don't to see whether the program meets its goal of preventing future hospital visits.
"Ideally, most policies going forward would have an evaluation component built in so that we can tell the effects of a program," Finkelstein says. "My real hope is that this will become a movement."
Explore further: MIT economist explains why randomized trials can improve medical care
This story is republished courtesy of MIT News (http://ift.tt/ABbm9r), a popular site that covers news about MIT research, innovation and teaching.
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
MIT economist explains why randomized trials can improve medical care
Feb 13, 2015
About 80 percent of studies of U.S. medical interventions use randomized controlled trials (RCTs), the gold standard of laboratory research. But only about 18 percent of studies of U.S. health care delivery ...
Having Medicaid increases emergency room visits
Jan 02, 2014
Adults who are covered by Medicaid use emergency rooms 40 percent more than those in similar circumstances who do not have health insurance, according to a unique new study, co-authored by an MIT economist, that sheds empirical ...
Expanding Medicaid: Mental and financial health improve, but no improvement shown in physical health
May 01, 2013
New findings from the Oregon Health Insurance Experiment show that Medicaid coverage had no detectable effect on the prevalence of diabetes, high cholesterol, or high blood pressure, but substantially reduced depression, ...
Study finds health insurance helps lower-income Americans avoid depression, diabetes, major financial shocks
May 03, 2013
Enrollment in Medicaid helps lower-income Americans overcome depression, get proper treatment for diabetes, and avoid catastrophic medical bills, but does not appear to reduce the prevalence of diabetes, high blood pressure ...
New insight: Consumers avoid high-deductible plans if they expect to reduce their use of medical care
Feb 27, 2013
Economists often talk about "moral hazard," the idea that people's behavior changes in the presence of insurance. In finance, for instance, investors may take more risks if they know they will be bailed out, ...
Recommended for you
Insuring undocumented residents could help solve multiple US health care challenges
40 minutes ago
Latinos are the largest ethnic minority group in the United States, and it's expected that by 2050 they will comprise almost 30 percent of the U.S. population. Yet they are also the most underserved by health care and health ...
Researchers find towels to be a top source of cross contamination within the kitchen
1 hour ago
Although only 9 percent of reported foodborne illness outbreaks occur in the home, scientists estimate the actual number of incidents is much higher. Research shows a leading cause of cross contamination ...
Excessive vitamin intake in pregnant rats impacts food choices in offspring
1 hour ago
A research group at the Department of Nutritional Sciences at the University of Toronto, Faculty of Medicine has been using a rat model to see how maternal intake of above-requirement vitamins (A, D, E, and K) impact offspring's ...
Poll: Many see negative impact if court nixes health law aid
3 hours ago
With a decision due by summer in a Supreme Court case that could unravel President Barack Obama's health care law, a new poll finds many Americans have heard nothing about the case. But when the potential ...
New tobacco atlas details scale, harms of tobacco epidemic
4 hours ago
The Tobacco Atlas, Fifth Edition ("The Atlas"), and its companion mobile app and website TobaccoAtlas.org, were unveiled today by the American Cancer Society and World Lung Foundation at the 16th World Conference on Tobacco o ...
Melatonin can help you get a good night's sleep in a noisy environment
10 hours ago
Using melatonin could provide more and better quality sleep compared to using an eye mask and earplugs in a simulated noisy and illuminated environment, according to research published in open access journal Critical Care. This s ...
User comments
Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more
Click here
to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.
© Medical Xpress 2011-2014, Science X network
0 comments:
Post a Comment