A study by scientists at the University of Granada (UGR) has shown that neither flashing traffic lights and nor the colour yellow have any effect on pedestrians. Only the two mandatory phases–steady green and steady red–are deterrents for pedestrians, communicating a clear, safe message.
The research–published in the the Spanish Journal of Psychology–was conducted by scientists at the UGR's "Brain Mind and Behavior" Research Center. The aim was to contribute to the design of more effective traffic signals to prevent people taking risks at traffic light controlled crosswalks.
The authors worked with a sample of 247 participants, most of whom (74.89%) had a valid driving license. All were presented with a series of photographs of various pedestrian crosswalks controlled by traffic lights in the centre of Granada.
Participants were shown different crosswalks with both real and modified traffic light regulation. They were asked to rate each situation from 1 to 10 as to whether or not they would cross (1 being "Never cross in that situation" and 10 "Always cross in that situation").
The types of traffic light that the researchers suggested to participants were: a steady green light, flashing green, steady yellow, flashing yellow, steady red, flashing red and lights off.
Steady red and green, the most effective
The results revealed some curious facts. Many pedestrians do not know the meaning of the non-mandatory phases of traffic lights, that is, those other than green (go) or red (don't-go). In addition, the options involving a flashing light and the colour yellow are not effective at communicating a clear, safemessage.
The researchers found that the mandatory solutions (steady green/steady red) are the best options to avoid unsafe pedestrian behaviour when crossing at controlled crosswalks.
University of Granada researchers Leandro L. Di Stasi and Alberto Megías–principal authors of the study–say that "in the European Union there are no specific, common regulations for traffic signals. For example, in Italy, as well as steady green/steady red, there is a yellow phase for pedestrians. In France, there is a flashing red phase, and in Spanish cities like Granada, a flashing green light indicates an imminent change to red".
Sand glass
Di Stasi and Megías suggest that introducing an easy, effective solution to create safer, pedestrian-friendly environments "would be to use a traffic light that only has the two mandatory phases–green and red–with an indication of the time remaining before the switch to the next phase: for example, an image of a sand glass with a countdown".
Another type of light that they consider would be effective is called a Marshalite, which was first used in Australia in 1936 and takes its name from Charles Marshall who designed it. Marshalites were used there for thirty years. They had two motorized rotors that moved hands like on a clock face to point to the relevant section: red, yellow or green.
The researchers suggest that the lack of common standards and the ambiguous messages about intermediate stages (steady or flashing lights) "could diminish road safety levels, contributing to the high number of accidents that occur annually in Europe at signalised junctions–equally common in Spain, according to the Spanish Interior Ministry's Directorate-General for Traffic (DGT)"
Explore further: Traffic light food labels strengthen self-control
More information: "The Influence of Traffic Signal Solutions on Self-Reported Road-Crossing Behavior." The Spanish Journal of Psychology (2014), 17, e103, 1–7. DOI: 10.1017/sjp.2014.105
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Pedestrians at serious risk when drivers are 'permitted' to turn left, study says
A study to examine driver behavior in permitted left turns has identified what researchers call an "alarming" level of risk to pedestrians crossing the street – about 4-9 percent of the time, drivers don't ...
Traffic light food labels strengthen self-control
Should food products be labeled with traffic light symbols to make health-related information on ingredients easier to understand? This question has remained a subject of debate. Now researchers at the University ...
Audi shows TLA solution to make those green lights (w/ Video)
(Phys.org) —The CES show in Las Vegas from January 7 to 10 provided a generous share of driver assistance technologies, where spectators were told how they can expect to interact with their cars as never ...
Stopping at red lights exposes drivers to high levels of air pollution, new study finds
Research published today in the journal Atmospheric Environment has found that drivers are exposed to dangerously high levels of air pollutants when stopped at red lights.
Virtual traffic lights as in-car systems go with the real road flow
Researchers have been working on a system of virtual traffic lights positioned inside the car which could give time back to commuters. For workers who make their way through daily traffic, the proposal is ...
Recommended for you
Game played in sync increases children's perceived similarity, closeness
What helps children who have just met form a connection? A new study shows that a simple game played together in sync on a computer led 8-year-olds to report a greater sense of similarity and closeness immediately ...
Depressed? Apps lift mood with personalized therapy
Feeling blue or anxious? Now, there's a mobile 'therapist' designed to understand you and suggest the ideal mini-app to lift your particular mood.
Don't blame kids if they do not enjoy school, study suggests
When children are unmotivated at school, new research suggests their genes may be part of the equation.
Rural African-American women had lower rates of depression, mood disorder
African-American women who live in rural areas have lower rates of major depressive disorder (MDD) and mood disorder compared with their urban counterparts, while rural non-Hispanic white women have higher rates for both ...
Mental disorders and physical diseases co-occur in teenagers
Every third teenager has suffered from one mental disorder and one physical disease. These co-occurrences come in specific associations: More often than average, depression occurs together with diseases of ...
Friends' character insights contain clues to longevity
Your friends may know you better than you know yourself. Personality traits you display in your 20s hold clues to how long you'll live – and your friends can judge these traits better than you, researchers ...
User comments
Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more
Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.
A study by scientists at the University of Granada (UGR) has shown that neither flashing traffic lights and nor the colour yellow have any effect on pedestrians. Only the two mandatory phases–steady green and steady red–are deterrents for pedestrians, communicating a clear, safe message.
The research–published in the the Spanish Journal of Psychology–was conducted by scientists at the UGR's "Brain Mind and Behavior" Research Center. The aim was to contribute to the design of more effective traffic signals to prevent people taking risks at traffic light controlled crosswalks.
The authors worked with a sample of 247 participants, most of whom (74.89%) had a valid driving license. All were presented with a series of photographs of various pedestrian crosswalks controlled by traffic lights in the centre of Granada.
Participants were shown different crosswalks with both real and modified traffic light regulation. They were asked to rate each situation from 1 to 10 as to whether or not they would cross (1 being "Never cross in that situation" and 10 "Always cross in that situation").
The types of traffic light that the researchers suggested to participants were: a steady green light, flashing green, steady yellow, flashing yellow, steady red, flashing red and lights off.
Steady red and green, the most effective
The results revealed some curious facts. Many pedestrians do not know the meaning of the non-mandatory phases of traffic lights, that is, those other than green (go) or red (don't-go). In addition, the options involving a flashing light and the colour yellow are not effective at communicating a clear, safemessage.
The researchers found that the mandatory solutions (steady green/steady red) are the best options to avoid unsafe pedestrian behaviour when crossing at controlled crosswalks.
University of Granada researchers Leandro L. Di Stasi and Alberto Megías–principal authors of the study–say that "in the European Union there are no specific, common regulations for traffic signals. For example, in Italy, as well as steady green/steady red, there is a yellow phase for pedestrians. In France, there is a flashing red phase, and in Spanish cities like Granada, a flashing green light indicates an imminent change to red".
Sand glass
Di Stasi and Megías suggest that introducing an easy, effective solution to create safer, pedestrian-friendly environments "would be to use a traffic light that only has the two mandatory phases–green and red–with an indication of the time remaining before the switch to the next phase: for example, an image of a sand glass with a countdown".
Another type of light that they consider would be effective is called a Marshalite, which was first used in Australia in 1936 and takes its name from Charles Marshall who designed it. Marshalites were used there for thirty years. They had two motorized rotors that moved hands like on a clock face to point to the relevant section: red, yellow or green.
The researchers suggest that the lack of common standards and the ambiguous messages about intermediate stages (steady or flashing lights) "could diminish road safety levels, contributing to the high number of accidents that occur annually in Europe at signalised junctions–equally common in Spain, according to the Spanish Interior Ministry's Directorate-General for Traffic (DGT)"
Explore further: Traffic light food labels strengthen self-control
More information: "The Influence of Traffic Signal Solutions on Self-Reported Road-Crossing Behavior." The Spanish Journal of Psychology (2014), 17, e103, 1–7. DOI: 10.1017/sjp.2014.105
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Pedestrians at serious risk when drivers are 'permitted' to turn left, study says
A study to examine driver behavior in permitted left turns has identified what researchers call an "alarming" level of risk to pedestrians crossing the street – about 4-9 percent of the time, drivers don't ...
Traffic light food labels strengthen self-control
Should food products be labeled with traffic light symbols to make health-related information on ingredients easier to understand? This question has remained a subject of debate. Now researchers at the University ...
Audi shows TLA solution to make those green lights (w/ Video)
(Phys.org) —The CES show in Las Vegas from January 7 to 10 provided a generous share of driver assistance technologies, where spectators were told how they can expect to interact with their cars as never ...
Stopping at red lights exposes drivers to high levels of air pollution, new study finds
Research published today in the journal Atmospheric Environment has found that drivers are exposed to dangerously high levels of air pollutants when stopped at red lights.
Virtual traffic lights as in-car systems go with the real road flow
Researchers have been working on a system of virtual traffic lights positioned inside the car which could give time back to commuters. For workers who make their way through daily traffic, the proposal is ...
Recommended for you
Game played in sync increases children's perceived similarity, closeness
What helps children who have just met form a connection? A new study shows that a simple game played together in sync on a computer led 8-year-olds to report a greater sense of similarity and closeness immediately ...
Depressed? Apps lift mood with personalized therapy
Feeling blue or anxious? Now, there's a mobile 'therapist' designed to understand you and suggest the ideal mini-app to lift your particular mood.
Don't blame kids if they do not enjoy school, study suggests
When children are unmotivated at school, new research suggests their genes may be part of the equation.
Rural African-American women had lower rates of depression, mood disorder
African-American women who live in rural areas have lower rates of major depressive disorder (MDD) and mood disorder compared with their urban counterparts, while rural non-Hispanic white women have higher rates for both ...
Mental disorders and physical diseases co-occur in teenagers
Every third teenager has suffered from one mental disorder and one physical disease. These co-occurrences come in specific associations: More often than average, depression occurs together with diseases of ...
Friends' character insights contain clues to longevity
Your friends may know you better than you know yourself. Personality traits you display in your 20s hold clues to how long you'll live – and your friends can judge these traits better than you, researchers ...
User comments
Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more
Click here
to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.
0 comments:
Post a Comment