A considerable body of health policy research has documented differences in hospital characteristics as contributing factors to differences in the quality of care. An article appearing in the October issue of Health Affairs examines the extent to which a patient's type—or lack—of insurance may also play a role. Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health authors, Darrell J. Gaskin, PhD, Associate Professor, Health Policy and Management, and Eric Roberts, MA, PhD candidate in health economics, along with author, Christine S. Spencer, ScD, executive director of the School of Health and Human Services at the University or Baltimore, compared hospital quality for patients according to their insurance status using pooled 2006-08 State Inpatient Database records from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ).
They compared in-hospital quality according to patients' health insurance using AHRQ's innovative Inpatient Quality Indicators. Specifically, they look at risk of dying in the hospital for patients admitted for common surgical procedures and medical conditions. Examples are hip replacement, coronary by-pass surgery, heart attack and pneumonia. Among the findings: Patients with private insurance had lower-than-expected mortality for 12 of 15 quality indicators compared to Medicare. However, Medicare patients had better outcomes for congestive heart failure, stroke and pneumonia than privately insured patients.
"The study suggests that within-hospital differences in quality exist across payer types. In particular, patients with Medicare appear to receive notably worse care than patients with private insurance on the majority of Inpatient Quality Indicators," said Gaskin. Mortality rates are influenced by the characteristics of both hospitals and patients, which suggests that specific policy interventions should vary by Inpatient Quality Indicator, type of hospital, and type of payer. In addition, there were several indicators on which privately insured patients received notably worse care than patients in the other payer groups. Spencer concludes, "We recommend that policymakers pay particular attention to how well patients fare under various insurance plans, since the type of insurance does appear to make a difference in the care that hospitals provide."
Explore further: Hospital readmission rates linked with quality of surgical care
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Hospital readmission rates linked with quality of surgical care
Sep 18, 2013
Reducing hospital readmission rates is an important clinical and policy priority but whether those rates really measure the quality of hospital care isn't clear. In a new study, researchers from Harvard School of Public Health ...
Medicaid patients at higher risk of complications after spine surgery
Jul 15, 2013
Among patients undergoing spinal surgery, Medicaid beneficiaries are at higher risk of experiencing any type of complication, compared to privately insured patients, reports a study in the July 15 issue of of Spine.
Uninsured brain cancer patients may be more likely than insured to die after surgery to remove tumor
Nov 19, 2012
Uninsured patients who undergo surgery to remove a brain tumor could be twice as likely to die in the hospital as those who have the same operation but are privately insured, new Johns Hopkins research suggests. In teaching ...
Study: Technology, not uninsured patients, driving hospital costs
Oct 02, 2013
Technology, not uninsured patients, likely explains the steep rise in the cost of hospital care in Texas in recent years, according to Vivian Ho, the chair in health economics at Rice University's Baker Institute for Public ...
Better short-Term outcomes for private prostatectomies
Mar 30, 2012
(HealthDay) -- For men undergoing radical prostatectomies (RPs), private health insurance coverage is linked with fewer complications, less in-hospital recovery time, and decreased mortality, compared to public ...
Recommended for you
EU Parliament bans menthol, targets e-cigarettes
7 minutes ago
European lawmakers have approved sweeping new regulations to curb smoking, including limits on electronic cigarettes, bigger warnings on cigarette packs and a ban on menthol.
Teenagers put-off smoking by standardised tobacco packaging
19 minutes ago
(Medical Xpress)—A new survey adds further weight to the growing evidence that standardised tobacco packaging could help discourage teenagers from smoking.
Building stronger bones one runner at a time
40 minutes ago
(Medical Xpress)—Helping others avoid the broken bones she had as a teenager motivated Wake Forest senior Aubrey Bledsoe to work with a health and exercise science professor to study bone health in athletes.
Eating disorders often associated with reproductive health problems
45 minutes ago
Women with eating disorders are less likely to have children than others in the same age group, indicates a study conducted at the University of Helsinki, Finland. The likelihood for miscarriage was more than triple for binge-eating ...
GPs unlikely to recommend alternative duties for injured workers
1 hour ago
Victorian General Practitioners (GPs) are more likely to order ill or injured workers stay away from work than recommend alternative duties, according to an Australian first study.
EU lawmakers to push ahead with anti-tobacco plans (Update)
3 hours ago
European lawmakers on Tuesday were set to tighten rules governing the multibillion-dollar tobacco market by imposing bigger and bolder warnings on cigarette packs, banning most flavorings like menthol and strengthening regulation ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
A considerable body of health policy research has documented differences in hospital characteristics as contributing factors to differences in the quality of care. An article appearing in the October issue of Health Affairs examines the extent to which a patient's type—or lack—of insurance may also play a role. Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health authors, Darrell J. Gaskin, PhD, Associate Professor, Health Policy and Management, and Eric Roberts, MA, PhD candidate in health economics, along with author, Christine S. Spencer, ScD, executive director of the School of Health and Human Services at the University or Baltimore, compared hospital quality for patients according to their insurance status using pooled 2006-08 State Inpatient Database records from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ).
They compared in-hospital quality according to patients' health insurance using AHRQ's innovative Inpatient Quality Indicators. Specifically, they look at risk of dying in the hospital for patients admitted for common surgical procedures and medical conditions. Examples are hip replacement, coronary by-pass surgery, heart attack and pneumonia. Among the findings: Patients with private insurance had lower-than-expected mortality for 12 of 15 quality indicators compared to Medicare. However, Medicare patients had better outcomes for congestive heart failure, stroke and pneumonia than privately insured patients.
"The study suggests that within-hospital differences in quality exist across payer types. In particular, patients with Medicare appear to receive notably worse care than patients with private insurance on the majority of Inpatient Quality Indicators," said Gaskin. Mortality rates are influenced by the characteristics of both hospitals and patients, which suggests that specific policy interventions should vary by Inpatient Quality Indicator, type of hospital, and type of payer. In addition, there were several indicators on which privately insured patients received notably worse care than patients in the other payer groups. Spencer concludes, "We recommend that policymakers pay particular attention to how well patients fare under various insurance plans, since the type of insurance does appear to make a difference in the care that hospitals provide."
Explore further: Hospital readmission rates linked with quality of surgical care
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Hospital readmission rates linked with quality of surgical care
Sep 18, 2013
Reducing hospital readmission rates is an important clinical and policy priority but whether those rates really measure the quality of hospital care isn't clear. In a new study, researchers from Harvard School of Public Health ...
Medicaid patients at higher risk of complications after spine surgery
Jul 15, 2013
Among patients undergoing spinal surgery, Medicaid beneficiaries are at higher risk of experiencing any type of complication, compared to privately insured patients, reports a study in the July 15 issue of of Spine.
Uninsured brain cancer patients may be more likely than insured to die after surgery to remove tumor
Nov 19, 2012
Uninsured patients who undergo surgery to remove a brain tumor could be twice as likely to die in the hospital as those who have the same operation but are privately insured, new Johns Hopkins research suggests. In teaching ...
Study: Technology, not uninsured patients, driving hospital costs
Oct 02, 2013
Technology, not uninsured patients, likely explains the steep rise in the cost of hospital care in Texas in recent years, according to Vivian Ho, the chair in health economics at Rice University's Baker Institute for Public ...
Better short-Term outcomes for private prostatectomies
Mar 30, 2012
(HealthDay) -- For men undergoing radical prostatectomies (RPs), private health insurance coverage is linked with fewer complications, less in-hospital recovery time, and decreased mortality, compared to public ...
Recommended for you
EU Parliament bans menthol, targets e-cigarettes
7 minutes ago
European lawmakers have approved sweeping new regulations to curb smoking, including limits on electronic cigarettes, bigger warnings on cigarette packs and a ban on menthol.
Teenagers put-off smoking by standardised tobacco packaging
19 minutes ago
(Medical Xpress)—A new survey adds further weight to the growing evidence that standardised tobacco packaging could help discourage teenagers from smoking.
Building stronger bones one runner at a time
40 minutes ago
(Medical Xpress)—Helping others avoid the broken bones she had as a teenager motivated Wake Forest senior Aubrey Bledsoe to work with a health and exercise science professor to study bone health in athletes.
Eating disorders often associated with reproductive health problems
45 minutes ago
Women with eating disorders are less likely to have children than others in the same age group, indicates a study conducted at the University of Helsinki, Finland. The likelihood for miscarriage was more than triple for binge-eating ...
GPs unlikely to recommend alternative duties for injured workers
1 hour ago
Victorian General Practitioners (GPs) are more likely to order ill or injured workers stay away from work than recommend alternative duties, according to an Australian first study.
EU lawmakers to push ahead with anti-tobacco plans (Update)
3 hours ago
European lawmakers on Tuesday were set to tighten rules governing the multibillion-dollar tobacco market by imposing bigger and bolder warnings on cigarette packs, banning most flavorings like menthol and strengthening regulation ...
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
0 comments:
Post a Comment