Targeting screening at deprived areas is a more cost effective way of identifying people in ethnic minority groups at high risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) than mass screening and may help to reduce health inequalities.
Despite recent improvements, CVD remains the leading cause of early death in the UK and many ethnic minority groups are at increased risk of the condition.
Currently, there are two ways of detecting individuals who require health interventions: mass screening or targeted screening, and policy makers must decide the best and most cost-effective course of action.
In order to examine the merits of both methods researchers at the University of Glasgow simulated the two screening strategies using cross-sectional data from Health Survey for England, comprising data from 9,407 adults aged 40-74 years.
They looked at the proportion of high-risk individuals that would be identified, how many would need to be screened to find one person at high-risk and how much this would cost.
Lead researcher Dr Jessica Baker, of the Institute of Health and Wellbeing, said: "We need to make sure that the interventions we use to improve the population's health do not increase health inequalities by disadvantaging important sections of the population.
"While mass screening could identify all high-risk individuals, targeting screening at deprived communities might be more cost-effective. In England, screening is offered to all middle-aged adults, while in Scotland intervention programmes are targeted at the most deprived.
"Given the cost of such screening we wanted to assess the impact of each method on ethnic minority populations."
After analysing the data the researchers found that targeted screening was more cost-effective than mass screening in all ethnic minority groups and was particularly efficient in the Pakistani and Bangladeshi population.
If people living in the poorest areas were screened it would cost £98 to find one high-risk person from the general population. This contrasts with the Pakistani and Bangladeshi population where it would only cost £59 because fewer people would need to be screened to find one high-risk person.
Dr Baker said: "Sometimes interventions that improve the health of the population as a whole can increase the health gap between different kinds of people.
"Our results demonstrate that targeted screening is an appropriate way of preventing CVD, and has the potential to reduce health inequalities between ethnic groups."
The research is published in the journal Heart.
Explore further: Research reveals deep divide in who gets best access to most desirable housing in England and Wales
More information: heart.bmj.com/content/early/2013/10/03/heartjnl-2013-304625.full.pdf+html
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Research reveals deep divide in who gets best access to most desirable housing in England and Wales
Oct 03, 2013
New research from University of Manchester sociologists has revealed a deep divide in who gets the best access to the most desirable housing in England and Wales.
Screening at-risk adolescents for celiac disease proves cost-effective
Jun 10, 2013
The current standard practice of screening adolescents who are either symptomatic or at high-risk for celiac disease proves to be more cost-effective than universal screening. Additionally, the strategy is successful in preventing ...
Repeat aneurysm screening for high-risk men should be considered
Jul 05, 2012
Aneurysm screening for men aged over 65 is cost effective and rescreening those at highest risk, at least once, should be considered, suggests a study published in the British Medical Journal today.
Additional blood pressure screening may reduce incidence of CVD events and death by up to 3 percent
Apr 22, 2012
A 25 per cent increase in high blood pressure screening in 19 developing countries would reduce the number of cardiovascular disease (CVD) events and deaths that occur each year by up to 3 per cent in these countries. The ...
Trial finds more support for universal HIV screening in emergency departments
Aug 06, 2013
Screening everyone for HIV in the emergency department may be superior to testing only those with apparent risk, when trying to identify patients with undiagnosed HIV infection, according to a new results by researchers at ...
Recommended for you
Does a patient's type of medical insurance impact their quality of care in hospitals?
1 minute ago
A considerable body of health policy research has documented differences in hospital characteristics as contributing factors to differences in the quality of care. An article appearing in the October issue of Health Affairs examin ...
EU Parliament bans menthol, targets e-cigarettes
8 minutes ago
European lawmakers have approved sweeping new regulations to curb smoking, including limits on electronic cigarettes, bigger warnings on cigarette packs and a ban on menthol.
Teenagers put-off smoking by standardised tobacco packaging
21 minutes ago
(Medical Xpress)—A new survey adds further weight to the growing evidence that standardised tobacco packaging could help discourage teenagers from smoking.
Building stronger bones one runner at a time
41 minutes ago
(Medical Xpress)—Helping others avoid the broken bones she had as a teenager motivated Wake Forest senior Aubrey Bledsoe to work with a health and exercise science professor to study bone health in athletes.
Eating disorders often associated with reproductive health problems
46 minutes ago
Women with eating disorders are less likely to have children than others in the same age group, indicates a study conducted at the University of Helsinki, Finland. The likelihood for miscarriage was more than triple for binge-eating ...
GPs unlikely to recommend alternative duties for injured workers
1 hour ago
Victorian General Practitioners (GPs) are more likely to order ill or injured workers stay away from work than recommend alternative duties, according to an Australian first study.
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
Targeting screening at deprived areas is a more cost effective way of identifying people in ethnic minority groups at high risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) than mass screening and may help to reduce health inequalities.
Despite recent improvements, CVD remains the leading cause of early death in the UK and many ethnic minority groups are at increased risk of the condition.
Currently, there are two ways of detecting individuals who require health interventions: mass screening or targeted screening, and policy makers must decide the best and most cost-effective course of action.
In order to examine the merits of both methods researchers at the University of Glasgow simulated the two screening strategies using cross-sectional data from Health Survey for England, comprising data from 9,407 adults aged 40-74 years.
They looked at the proportion of high-risk individuals that would be identified, how many would need to be screened to find one person at high-risk and how much this would cost.
Lead researcher Dr Jessica Baker, of the Institute of Health and Wellbeing, said: "We need to make sure that the interventions we use to improve the population's health do not increase health inequalities by disadvantaging important sections of the population.
"While mass screening could identify all high-risk individuals, targeting screening at deprived communities might be more cost-effective. In England, screening is offered to all middle-aged adults, while in Scotland intervention programmes are targeted at the most deprived.
"Given the cost of such screening we wanted to assess the impact of each method on ethnic minority populations."
After analysing the data the researchers found that targeted screening was more cost-effective than mass screening in all ethnic minority groups and was particularly efficient in the Pakistani and Bangladeshi population.
If people living in the poorest areas were screened it would cost £98 to find one high-risk person from the general population. This contrasts with the Pakistani and Bangladeshi population where it would only cost £59 because fewer people would need to be screened to find one high-risk person.
Dr Baker said: "Sometimes interventions that improve the health of the population as a whole can increase the health gap between different kinds of people.
"Our results demonstrate that targeted screening is an appropriate way of preventing CVD, and has the potential to reduce health inequalities between ethnic groups."
The research is published in the journal Heart.
Explore further: Research reveals deep divide in who gets best access to most desirable housing in England and Wales
More information: heart.bmj.com/content/early/2013/10/03/heartjnl-2013-304625.full.pdf+html
Medical Xpress on facebook
Related Stories
Research reveals deep divide in who gets best access to most desirable housing in England and Wales
Oct 03, 2013
New research from University of Manchester sociologists has revealed a deep divide in who gets the best access to the most desirable housing in England and Wales.
Screening at-risk adolescents for celiac disease proves cost-effective
Jun 10, 2013
The current standard practice of screening adolescents who are either symptomatic or at high-risk for celiac disease proves to be more cost-effective than universal screening. Additionally, the strategy is successful in preventing ...
Repeat aneurysm screening for high-risk men should be considered
Jul 05, 2012
Aneurysm screening for men aged over 65 is cost effective and rescreening those at highest risk, at least once, should be considered, suggests a study published in the British Medical Journal today.
Additional blood pressure screening may reduce incidence of CVD events and death by up to 3 percent
Apr 22, 2012
A 25 per cent increase in high blood pressure screening in 19 developing countries would reduce the number of cardiovascular disease (CVD) events and deaths that occur each year by up to 3 per cent in these countries. The ...
Trial finds more support for universal HIV screening in emergency departments
Aug 06, 2013
Screening everyone for HIV in the emergency department may be superior to testing only those with apparent risk, when trying to identify patients with undiagnosed HIV infection, according to a new results by researchers at ...
Recommended for you
Does a patient's type of medical insurance impact their quality of care in hospitals?
1 minute ago
A considerable body of health policy research has documented differences in hospital characteristics as contributing factors to differences in the quality of care. An article appearing in the October issue of Health Affairs examin ...
EU Parliament bans menthol, targets e-cigarettes
8 minutes ago
European lawmakers have approved sweeping new regulations to curb smoking, including limits on electronic cigarettes, bigger warnings on cigarette packs and a ban on menthol.
Teenagers put-off smoking by standardised tobacco packaging
21 minutes ago
(Medical Xpress)—A new survey adds further weight to the growing evidence that standardised tobacco packaging could help discourage teenagers from smoking.
Building stronger bones one runner at a time
41 minutes ago
(Medical Xpress)—Helping others avoid the broken bones she had as a teenager motivated Wake Forest senior Aubrey Bledsoe to work with a health and exercise science professor to study bone health in athletes.
Eating disorders often associated with reproductive health problems
46 minutes ago
Women with eating disorders are less likely to have children than others in the same age group, indicates a study conducted at the University of Helsinki, Finland. The likelihood for miscarriage was more than triple for binge-eating ...
GPs unlikely to recommend alternative duties for injured workers
1 hour ago
Victorian General Practitioners (GPs) are more likely to order ill or injured workers stay away from work than recommend alternative duties, according to an Australian first study.
User comments
© Medical Xpress 2011-2013, Phys.org network
0 comments:
Post a Comment